Dotting the “I think”
- This chapter discusses a central problem in Sebastian Rödl’s Self-Consciousness and Objectivity and in Wittgenstein’s Tractatus. In a statement of the form “I think p”, the words “I think” do not contribute to the content, and yet they are not redundant. In other words, a thinking subject is not something and yet not nothing. But then in what sense is a thinking subject a part of the world? The problem is intractable on a merely negative understanding of “I think”, like Anscombe’s merely negative thesis, endorsed by Rödl, that “I” is not a referring expression. In search of a positive understanding, this chapter proposes to understand “I think” by comparison to “hello”. A speaking subject is the expression of mutual presence in conversation – in that sense a limit of the world. Such expression may be compared to facial expression, with the crucial difference that a verbal expression can be taken up – i.e., repeated – in the third person. A speaking subject, then, is potentially absent from conversation, and in that sense a part of theThis chapter discusses a central problem in Sebastian Rödl’s Self-Consciousness and Objectivity and in Wittgenstein’s Tractatus. In a statement of the form “I think p”, the words “I think” do not contribute to the content, and yet they are not redundant. In other words, a thinking subject is not something and yet not nothing. But then in what sense is a thinking subject a part of the world? The problem is intractable on a merely negative understanding of “I think”, like Anscombe’s merely negative thesis, endorsed by Rödl, that “I” is not a referring expression. In search of a positive understanding, this chapter proposes to understand “I think” by comparison to “hello”. A speaking subject is the expression of mutual presence in conversation – in that sense a limit of the world. Such expression may be compared to facial expression, with the crucial difference that a verbal expression can be taken up – i.e., repeated – in the third person. A speaking subject, then, is potentially absent from conversation, and in that sense a part of the world.…
Verfasserangaben: | Martijn WallageORCiD |
---|---|
DOI: | https://doi.org//10.4324/9781003324638 |
ISBN: | 978-1-03-234951-0 |
ISBN: | 978-1-00-095669-6 |
Titel des übergeordneten Werks (Englisch): | Reading Rödl : On Self-Consciousness and Objectivity |
Untertitel (Deutsch): | Self-consciousness and punctuation |
Verlag: | Taylor & Francis Group |
Verlagsort: | Milton |
Publikationstyp: | Wissenschaftlicher Artikel |
Sprache: | Englisch |
Datum der Erstveröffentlichung: | 04.09.2023 |
Erscheinungsjahr: | 2023 |
Datum der Freischaltung: | 26.10.2023 |
Seitenanzahl: | 18 |
Erste Seite: | 316 |
Letzte Seite: | 333 |
Organisationseinheiten: | Philosophische Fakultät / Institut für Philosophie |
DDC-Klassifikation: | 1 Philosophie und Psychologie / 10 Philosophie / 100 Philosophie und Psychologie |