320 Politikwissenschaft
Refine
Year of publication
Document Type
- Article (146)
- Part of a Book (95)
- Monograph/Edited Volume (26)
- Other (21)
- Doctoral Thesis (13)
- Review (9)
- Master's Thesis (5)
- Report (3)
- Working Paper (3)
- Postprint (2)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (325)
Keywords
- Integration (7)
- Germany (5)
- Migration (5)
- Security Council (5)
- World Bank (5)
- decision-making (5)
- Politikunterricht (4)
- digitalization (4)
- discourse (4)
- governance (4)
- human rights (4)
- international organisations (4)
- Föderalismus (3)
- bicameralism (3)
- civil war (3)
- contestation (3)
- counterterrorism (3)
- crisis (3)
- democracy (3)
- executive personalism (3)
- institutional design (3)
- international organizations (3)
- parliamentary government (3)
- political education (3)
- semi-parliamentary government (3)
- separation of powers (3)
- territorial reforms (3)
- terrorism (3)
- value change (3)
- Australia (2)
- COVID-19 (2)
- Coordination (2)
- Deutschland (2)
- Eurobarometer (2)
- European Union (2)
- Ferdinand von Schirach (2)
- International (2)
- International Financial Institutions (2)
- Koordinierung (2)
- Krise (2)
- Krisenmanagement (2)
- Liberia (2)
- Local authorities (2)
- Politikberatung (2)
- Politische Bildung (2)
- United Nations (2)
- authoritarianism (2)
- bias (2)
- climate change (2)
- constitutional design (2)
- democratic theory (2)
- digital transformation (2)
- drug control (2)
- e-government (2)
- elections (2)
- feminism (2)
- gender (2)
- institutions (2)
- international (2)
- international law (2)
- international legal order (2)
- international non-governmental organizations (2)
- international public administration (2)
- international relations (2)
- legal change (2)
- lokale Behörden (2)
- margins of error (2)
- metamorphosis of international law (2)
- new public management (2)
- norm change (2)
- patterns of democracy (2)
- peacebuilding (2)
- policy (2)
- policy advice (2)
- presidential government (2)
- presidentialism (2)
- transitional justice (2)
- (Justiz-) Roman (1)
- (post) new public management (1)
- 1848/49 revolution (1)
- AKP (1)
- Active learning (1)
- Administration (1)
- Administrative reform (1)
- AfD (1)
- Al-Qaida (1)
- Alternative für Deutschland (1)
- Anti-Imperialismus (1)
- Antifeminismus (1)
- Antisemitism (1)
- Antisemitismus (1)
- Arbeitsmarkt (1)
- Artefakte (1)
- Aufsatzsammlung (1)
- Augmented reality (1)
- Ausländerbehörde (1)
- Auswertung (1)
- Automatisierung (1)
- Bedrohungsvorstellung (1)
- Benchmarking (1)
- Berliner Mauer (1)
- Beutelsbach consensus (1)
- Beutelsbacher Konsens (1)
- Bildung (1)
- Brasilien (1)
- Brazil (1)
- Bürgerbeteiligung (1)
- CORONA-Krise (1)
- COVID-19 pandemic (1)
- CPPS (1)
- CPS (1)
- Chancengleichheit (1)
- Changing nature of armed conflict (1)
- China (1)
- Circular argumentation (1)
- Civic Education (1)
- Civil society (1)
- Climate change (1)
- Comparative Public Administration (1)
- Compliance (1)
- Conseil de sécurité (1)
- Consejo de Seguridad (1)
- Constitutive Mechanism (1)
- Coordination structures (1)
- Counterterrorism (1)
- Country experience (1)
- Covid-19-Pandemie (1)
- Daten (1)
- Decarbonisation (1)
- Decision Probability (1)
- Decoloniale Theorie (1)
- Dekarbonisierung (1)
- Demokratie (1)
- Demokratieförderung (1)
- Demokratietheorie (1)
- Der Fall Collini (1)
- Development cooperation (1)
- Dezentralisierung (1)
- Dicranopteris linearis (1)
- Digitalisierung (1)
- Diskurs (1)
- Diskursanalyse (1)
- Diskurstheorie (1)
- EU external borders (1)
- EU-Außengrenzen (1)
- EU-Integration (1)
- Education (1)
- Effektivität (1)
- Egalitarismus (1)
- Electoral systems (1)
- Emanzipation (1)
- Energiesysteme (1)
- Energiewende (1)
- Enforcement (1)
- Entscheidungsunterstützung (1)
- Entwicklungstheorien (1)
- Entwicklungszusammenarbeit (1)
- Erde (1)
- Erdogan (1)
- Erneuerbare Energie (1)
- Erzählungen, (1)
- Europe (1)
- European Commission (1)
- European Green Deal (1)
- European Immigration Policies (1)
- Europäisierung (1)
- Existentialismus (1)
- Expert Authority (1)
- Federalism (1)
- Feminismus (1)
- Feministische Philosophie (1)
- Finanzrisiken (1)
- Flüchtlingskrise (1)
- Folter (1)
- Forms of government (1)
- Forschungsmethoden (1)
- Foucault (1)
- Frauen (1)
- Frauenbewegung (1)
- Frauenhass (1)
- Freiheit (1)
- GIZ (1)
- Gemeinden (1)
- Gender (1)
- Generalized knowledge constructin axiom (1)
- Gerechtigkeit (1)
- German science council (1)
- German women's movement (1)
- Gesundheit (1)
- Gewalt (1)
- Global South (1)
- Global order (1)
- Gobernanza de los Comités (1)
- Green infrastructure investment (1)
- Grundwerte (1)
- Hackathon (1)
- Hanau (1)
- Hochkommissariat für Menschenrechte (OHCHR) (1)
- IMF (1)
- INGOs (1)
- Identität (1)
- Impartiality (1)
- Incels (1)
- Industry 4.0 (1)
- Informal reform (1)
- Inhaltsanalyse (1)
- Institutional change (1)
- Integration Policy (1)
- Integration strategy (1)
- Integrationspolitik (1)
- Integrationsstrategie (1)
- Interdisciplinary research (1)
- Interdisziplinarität (1)
- International Bureaucracies (1)
- International Monetary Fund (1)
- International Practices (1)
- International bureaucrats (1)
- International cooperation (1)
- International relations (1)
- Internationale Beziehungen (1)
- Internationalisierung (1)
- Internet of things (1)
- Investitionsverhalten (1)
- Investment Behavior (1)
- Irak (1)
- Iran (1)
- Iraq (1)
- Isla Vista (1)
- Juden (1)
- Kategorienbildung (1)
- Klassik (1)
- Klimagovernance (1)
- Klimakrise (1)
- Klimapolitik (1)
- Klimawandel (1)
- Kommune (1)
- Kompetenzen (1)
- Kontext (1)
- Kontroversität (1)
- Kontroversitätsgebot (1)
- Künstliche Intelligenz (1)
- Lateinamerika (1)
- Legitimität (1)
- Lehrkompetenz (1)
- Leistungsverwaltung (1)
- Liberalismus (1)
- Lieferkettengesetz (1)
- Local Civil Society Networks (1)
- Local Governance (1)
- Local administrative systems (1)
- Local autonomy (1)
- Local government reform (1)
- Louise Otto-Peters (1)
- Lucha antiterrorista (1)
- Macht (1)
- Manosphere (1)
- Market Dynamics (1)
- Markt (1)
- Marktdynamik (1)
- Measurement theory (1)
- Media (1)
- Medien (1)
- Medizintechnik (1)
- Mehrebenen-System (1)
- Mehrebenensystem (1)
- Meinungsbildung (1)
- Mensch-Tier-Beziehung (1)
- Menschen- rechtserklärungen/-übereinkommen (1)
- Menschenrechte (1)
- Meta-model (1)
- Methodenpluralismus (1)
- Methodological pluralism (1)
- Migranten (1)
- Migrants (1)
- Migration Policy (1)
- Migrationspolitik (1)
- Mikropolitik (1)
- Modellierung (1)
- Moderation (1)
- Monetary Fund (1)
- Municipalities (1)
- Nachhaltigkeit (1)
- Nachwuchsförderung (1)
- Narration (1)
- Narrationen (1)
- Narrative (1)
- National state communication (1)
- Negotiation (1)
- Neoliberalismus (1)
- Neutrality (1)
- New public management (1)
- Nicht-Beherrschung (1)
- Nicht-ideale Theorie (1)
- Norm collisions (1)
- Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (1)
- Open Governance (1)
- Ordnungsverwaltung (1)
- Organisations (1)
- Othering (1)
- P/CVE (1)
- Pandemie (1)
- Paris Agreement (1)
- Peacebuilding (1)
- Performance (1)
- Pluralismus (1)
- Policy (1)
- Policy Changes (1)
- Policy recommendations (1)
- Politik (1)
- Politikänderungen (1)
- Poststrukturalismus (1)
- Potassium (1)
- Precedent (1)
- Proceso debido (1)
- Process modeling (1)
- Promoting young researchers (1)
- Prozessexpertise (1)
- Prozessgestaltung (1)
- Präferenzen (1)
- Public Management (1)
- Public opinion (1)
- Public-private partnerships (1)
- QCA (1)
- Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse (1)
- Quality management (1)
- Rankings (1)
- Ratchet Effect (1)
- Recht (1)
- Rechtserziehung (1)
- Rechtsextremismus (1)
- Rechtsstaat (1)
- Rechtsterrorismus (1)
- Recipient performance (1)
- Reddit (1)
- Regulierung (1)
- Religionsfreiheit (1)
- Renewable Energy (1)
- Republikanismus (1)
- Research methods (1)
- Responsibility to Protect (1)
- Revolution 1848/49 (1)
- Rio Conventions (1)
- Risikoauferlegung (1)
- Sachbearbeitung (1)
- Sanciones de la ONU (1)
- Sanktionen (1)
- Schulbuchanalyse (1)
- Sebastian Kurz (1)
- Security council (1)
- Security council reform (1)
- Serene Khader (1)
- Sexismus (1)
- Sicherheit (1)
- Sicherheitspolitik (1)
- Sicherheitsrat (1)
- Sierra Leone (1)
- Simulation process building (1)
- Simulations (1)
- Social Choice Theory (1)
- Soziale Gleichheit (1)
- Sozialer Status (1)
- Soziologie (1)
- Staatliche Leistungsfähigkeit (1)
- Stakeholder (1)
- Storytelling (1)
- Strafgerichtsverfahren (1)
- Sub-national Autonomy (1)
- Sudan (1)
- Supervision (1)
- Survey (1)
- Sustainability indicators (1)
- Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) (1)
- Syria (1)
- Systemisches Risiko (1)
- Terrorismus (1)
- The Collini Case (1)
- Transformation (1)
- Transformationsforschung (1)
- Transnationale Demokratie (1)
- Turkish politics (1)
- Types of democracy (1)
- UN (1)
- UN Security Council (1)
- UN human rights treaty bodies (1)
- UN sanctions (1)
- Umweltperformanz (1)
- Umweltpolitik (1)
- Universalismus (1)
- Unterrichtskonzeption (1)
- Unterrichtsmedium (1)
- Use cases Morphologic box (1)
- Verflechtung (1)
- Verschwindenlassen (1)
- Verwaltung (1)
- Veto Player (1)
- Vetopunkte (1)
- Vetospieler (1)
- Weak and strong sustainability (1)
- West Africa (1)
- Wicked problems (1)
- Winning Coalition (1)
- Wirksamkeit von Entwicklungspolitik (1)
- Wissenschaft (1)
- Wissenschaftsrat (1)
- Wissenssoziologie (1)
- Zivilgesellschaft (1)
- actor constellations (1)
- administration (1)
- administrative culture (1)
- administrative reforms (1)
- advocacy coalitions (1)
- agency (1)
- aid (1)
- aid allocation (1)
- aid effectiveness (1)
- anthropocene (1)
- anti-gender (1)
- antifeminist (1)
- artefacts (1)
- authoritarian resilience (1)
- authoritarian rule (1)
- authority (1)
- borders (1)
- boundary spanning (1)
- bourgeoisie (1)
- burden of disease (1)
- bürgerliches Frauenbild (1)
- capacity (1)
- challenges for international law (1)
- child labour (1)
- citizen participation (1)
- citizenship (1)
- civil service survey (1)
- civilian infrastructure (1)
- climate and energy policy (1)
- climate finance (1)
- climate governance (1)
- climate mitigation (1)
- climate policy (1)
- closing civic space (1)
- collaboration (1)
- collaborative governance (1)
- collective targeting (1)
- committee governance (1)
- comparative (1)
- comparative environmental politics (1)
- comparative public administration (1)
- competencies (1)
- complex problems (1)
- computerunterstütze Datenanalyse (1)
- conflict management (1)
- conflict resolution (1)
- consensus democracy (1)
- constitution-making (1)
- constitutional state (1)
- containment (1)
- contentious politics (1)
- coordination (1)
- corruption (1)
- criminal proceeding (1)
- crises (1)
- crisis management (1)
- data (1)
- data and methods (1)
- de facto authority (1)
- de jure authority (1)
- death (1)
- death penalty (1)
- decarbonization (1)
- decentralization (1)
- delegation (1)
- deliberative Demokratie (1)
- democratic performance (1)
- democratization (1)
- dependency (1)
- development (1)
- development projects (1)
- dictatorship (1)
- digital government (1)
- digital overload (1)
- digitale Demokratie (1)
- digitale Verwaltung (1)
- direct democracy (1)
- direkte Demokratie (1)
- disability-adjusted life years (1)
- discrimination (1)
- doctrine (1)
- domestic politics (1)
- drivers for change (1)
- due process (1)
- e-services (1)
- earth system governance (1)
- ecological modernization (1)
- effective district magnitude (1)
- energy (1)
- environmental degradation (1)
- environmental mainstreaming (1)
- environmental policy (1)
- environmental policy effects (1)
- environmental policy performance (1)
- epistemic injustice (1)
- epistemische Ungerechtigkeit (1)
- europäische Einwanderungspolitiken (1)
- executive head (1)
- executive-parties dimension (1)
- executives (1)
- expert authority (1)
- expert recommendations (1)
- expertise (1)
- facilitation (1)
- far right (1)
- far-right extremism (1)
- far-right groups (1)
- far-right parties (1)
- far-right populism (1)
- featured (1)
- federalism (1)
- fern (1)
- financial policy (1)
- fisheries policy (1)
- formale Modelle (1)
- fragile epistemische Subjekte (1)
- gender mainstreaming (1)
- gender research (1)
- geographical proximity (1)
- global commons (1)
- global environmental governance (1)
- global environmental politics (1)
- global governance (1)
- global health (1)
- global public policy (1)
- globale Umweltpolitik (1)
- globalization (1)
- gouvernance de comité (1)
- government policymaking (1)
- green finance (1)
- green recovery (1)
- hackathon (1)
- health security (1)
- health services (1)
- hermeneutical capability (1)
- hermeneutical injustice (1)
- higher education (1)
- history (1)
- hospitals (1)
- huella ecológica (1)
- human mind (1)
- human trafficking (1)
- human-animal relationship (1)
- impact evaluation (1)
- impartiality (1)
- incels (1)
- individual complaints procedures (1)
- information and communication technologies (1)
- institutional change (1)
- institutional interplay (1)
- institutional investors (1)
- institutional policy (1)
- institutional reform (1)
- institutional theory (1)
- inter-governmental relations (1)
- interdisciplinarity (1)
- intergovernmental reforms (1)
- intergovernmental treaty secretariats (1)
- international administration (1)
- international bureaucracy (1)
- international development (1)
- international institutions (1)
- international organisation (1)
- international trade (1)
- internationale Beziehungen (1)
- job autonomy (1)
- job satisfaction (1)
- just transition (1)
- justice (1)
- land management (1)
- law (1)
- law education (1)
- legislatures (1)
- legitimacy (1)
- liberalism (1)
- local and urban governance (1)
- local autonomy (1)
- local community (1)
- local finance (1)
- local government (1)
- local government systems (1)
- local politics (1)
- lokale Autonomie (1)
- lokale Netzwerke der Zivilgesellschaft (1)
- lokale Verwaltung (1)
- lutte contre le terrorisme (1)
- male supremacy (1)
- managerial reforms (1)
- manosphere (1)
- marine governance (1)
- men's rights (1)
- meso-level of government (1)
- micro-politics (1)
- micropolitics (1)
- minority rights (1)
- misogyny (1)
- modernización ecológica (1)
- modernization (1)
- multi-level governance (1)
- multi-level government (1)
- multi-level system (1)
- multi-party systems (1)
- multilateralism (1)
- multiplicity (1)
- municipalities (1)
- narration (1)
- narrative approach (1)
- narrativer Ansatz (1)
- national ecological footprint (1)
- nationale staatliche Kommunikation (1)
- nativism (1)
- natural climate solutions (1)
- neo weberian state (1)
- newsfeed (1)
- nineteenth and twentieth century (1)
- non-state actors (1)
- norm collisions (1)
- norm dynamics (1)
- norm robustness (1)
- norms (1)
- novel (1)
- open governance (1)
- opinion polls (1)
- orchestration (1)
- organization theory (1)
- organizational reform (1)
- organizational reputation (1)
- organizations (1)
- othering (1)
- pandemic (1)
- parliamentary democracy (1)
- partizipative Demokratie (1)
- party competition (1)
- pathozentrische epistemische Ungerechtigkeit (1)
- peace (1)
- peace process (1)
- peacekeeping (1)
- performance (1)
- phytolith (1)
- planetary boundaries (1)
- policy agendas (1)
- policy analysis (1)
- policy output (1)
- policy scope (1)
- policy signals (1)
- policy strategy (1)
- policy substitutes (1)
- political campaigns (1)
- political equality (1)
- political repression (1)
- political science (1)
- political stability (1)
- politics (1)
- politics and the media (1)
- politische Bildung (1)
- politische Einstellung (1)
- politische Kultur (1)
- politische Urteilsbildung (1)
- polling (1)
- política ambiental comparada (1)
- pooling (1)
- populist radical right (1)
- post-conflict peace (1)
- post-development (1)
- power (1)
- precedent (1)
- principle of controversy (1)
- problem-solving (1)
- process design (1)
- process expertise (1)
- process tracing (1)
- procédure officielle (1)
- protection (1)
- protest (1)
- public health (1)
- public management (1)
- public opinion polls (1)
- public participation (1)
- public sector reform (1)
- public value (1)
- public values (1)
- qualitative Daten (1)
- qualitative content analysis (1)
- racism (1)
- radical (1)
- radicalization (1)
- rationalism (1)
- rebel attacks (1)
- regime complexity (1)
- regional organizations (1)
- regulación estatal (1)
- regulation (1)
- renewable energy (1)
- representation (1)
- research (1)
- resilience (1)
- responsibility (1)
- restoration (1)
- restrictions to civil society (1)
- right parties and movements (1)
- right-wing politics (1)
- sanctions (1)
- sanctions committee (1)
- sanctions de l’ONU (1)
- scholar-practitioners (1)
- school book analysis (1)
- science (1)
- science & technology (1)
- second-order compliance (1)
- security–development nexus (1)
- selection (1)
- self-governance (1)
- semi-parliamentarism (1)
- set theory (1)
- social closure (1)
- social epistemology (1)
- social networking sites (1)
- soziale Schließung (1)
- state (1)
- state repression (1)
- state security (1)
- storytelling (1)
- structural change (1)
- subnationale Autonomie (1)
- survey (1)
- survey experiment (1)
- survival analysis (1)
- teaching (1)
- teaching concept (1)
- teaching tool (1)
- termination (1)
- territorial administration (1)
- trade-offs (1)
- transdisciplinarity (1)
- transition policy (1)
- treadmill of production (1)
- triple nexus (1)
- turnout (1)
- un-cancelling the future (1)
- vergleichende öffentliche Verwaltung (1)
- violence (1)
- vote choice (1)
- vote switching (1)
- voters (1)
- voting (1)
- window of opportunity (1)
- world bank (1)
- world-makers (1)
- ÖVP (1)
- Öffentliche Verwaltung (1)
- öffentliche Meinung (1)
Institute
- Fachgruppe Politik- & Verwaltungswissenschaft (325) (remove)
Moderne Bürgerreligion
(2011)
Each year, donor countries spend billions of Euros on development cooperation. Not surprisingly, a large strand of research has emerged which examines the impact of development cooperation. A sub-discipline within this strand of the literature deals with the question of whether the impact or effectiveness of development cooperation depends on the quality of the recipient country's policy and institutional environment. Over hundreds of studies have assessed this question at the macro level. In so doing, most of these studies test whether a potential effect of aid on the growth of a recipient country’s gross domestic product (GDP) is conditional on the country's policy and institutional environment. However, even after decades of research and hundreds of studies, no conclusive result has been found. One of the main reasons for the inconclusive state of the literature is that most macro-level studies have to deal with a high risk of endogeneity, treat aid as nothing but a pure income transfer, and rely on low-quality GDP data. To solve these three methodical issues, some authors have started to change the analytical focus from the macro to the micro level. Thus, these authors assess the determinants for the performance of individual development projects instead of the determinants for an effect of aid on GDP. Yet, even though the number of studies focusing on the micro level has increased steadily over the last few years, the state of the literature on the determinants for the performance of development projects still contains multiple highly relevant research gaps. The present thesis seeks to address three of these research gaps. The first research gap addressed by this thesis is related to the specific type of development cooperation. So far, nearly all existing studies focus on projects by Multilateral Development Banks. Research on the determinants for the performance of bilateral development projects is still rare. Thus, even though donors pledge to implement effective development projects, there are hardly any micro-level studies on bilateral projects. So far, only three studies use a sample which includes bilateral projects. Yet, none of the three studies assess the determinants for the performance of bilateral technical development projects. The first paper in the present thesis (GIZ paper) seeks to address this research gap by assessing the determinants for the performance of projects by the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ), a bilateral state-owned aid agency active in the area of technical cooperation. The results of the paper indicate that some but not all of the existing theoretical arguments can be extended to bilateral technical projects as well.. For example, the level of market interventions in the recipient county only affects the performance of financial development projects, while the recipient country’s government capacity affects both technical and financial development projects. The paper also indicates that effects of determinants may vary among project sectors. The paper also highlights a dilemma of technical development cooperation. The countries with low government capacity are usually the ones most in need of technical cooperation projects. But, at the same time, they are also the countries in which these projects have the poorest performance The second research gap addressed by this thesis is related to one specific factor in the policy and institutional environment of recipient countries, namely corruption. This determinant is often cited as essential for project performance but has gained surprisingly little coverage in empirical studies. The few existing studies on the effect of corruption on project performance are inconclusive. Some find a statistically significant correlation, while others do not. Furthermore, so far, all existing studies use corruption perception indices as a measurement for corruption, despite the fact that these indices have well-known deficits when it comes to this research topic. One of these deficits is that such indices do not distinguish between different forms of corruption, even though it is likely that the effect of corruption will vary depending on the type of development project and form of corruption. The second paper in this thesis (Corruption paper) seeks to address this inconclusive state of the research while focusing on one specific form of corruption, namely bribery between private firms and public officials. The paper finds a small but statistically significant correlation between the corruption level and the performance of World Bank projects. The systematic effect of corruption on project performance confirms the need to consider the risk of corruption in the design and during the implementation of projects. Nonetheless, the relatively small effect of corruption and the low pseudo R-squareds advise not to overestimate the relevance of corruption for project performance. At least for the project level, the paper finds no indication that corruption is a primary obstacle to aid effectiveness. The third research gap addressed by this thesis is related to one specific sample, namely recipient countries of the International Development Association (IDA). The question of whether the policy and institutional environment affects project performance is of particular relevance for these countries, given that the World Bank's ratings on a country's policy and institutional environment decide how much IDA resources it receives. One core justification of such an allocation system is that it helps to steer more resources to places where they are most effective. However, so far, there is no conclusive empirical evidence for this statement. The only study specifically focusing on this topic, a study by the Independent Evaluation Group of the World Bank from 2010, has essential methodological limitations. The third paper of this thesis (CPR paper) seeks to address this research gap by testing whether a more refined analysis confirms the assumption of previous studies that the policy and institutional environment of IDA-recipient countries, measured by the Country Policy and Institutional Assessment ratings, has an effect on the performance of World Bank projects. Overall, neither the main regression models nor any of the robustness tests indicate a substantial correlation between the policy and institutional environment and project performance. Only for Investments Loans is the coefficient large enough to assume some effect. The overall results not only contradict the results of previous studies, but also raise strong doubts around one of the core justifications for the allocation system of the IDA. All three papers rely on a statistical large-N analysis of the performance ratings of individual development projects. These ratings are usually assigned based on the final evaluation of a project and indicate the merit or worth of an activity. The merit or worth of an activity itself is measured by criteria like relevance, effectiveness, and efficiency. In the case of the two papers on World Bank projects, the needed data stem from different databases of the World Bank. The relevant data for the GIZ paper are gathered from internal evaluation reports of the GIZ. Logistic regressions are applied as the main analytical tool. Overall, the three papers show that the policy and institutional environment of recipient countries matters for project performance, but only to a small degree and under certain circumstances. This result highlights that many researchers and practitioners tend to overestimate the role that the policy and institutional environment of recipient countries plays in project performance. Furthermore, the thesis shows that authors of future studies should consider possible interactions between project- and country-level determinants whenever possible, both in their theoretical arguments and statistical models. Otherwise, the debate on the determinants for project performance is at risk of degenerating into a statistics tournament without any connection to reality.