Refine
Has Fulltext
- yes (2)
Document Type
- Master's Thesis (2) (remove)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (2) (remove)
Keywords
- Jewish denominations (2) (remove)
Institute
This study on the Messianic Jewish movement and its relationship to the Torah explores the various aspects of the relationship to the Torah on the basis of 10 interviews with selected Yeshua-believing Jews in leadership positions. The selection of interviewees results in a range of different positions typical of the movement as a whole, which overlap in many respects but are often fundamentally different and sometimes contradictory. Particular attention is paid to the theologically based, divergent and contradictory positions in an attempt to make these understandable.
After a brief introduction to the Messianic Jewish movement, aspects of the Messianic Jewish dual identity are examined and their relevance for the relationship to the Torah is demonstrated. This is followed by an overview of the forums in which Yeshua-believing Jews discuss their relationship to the Torah. The extensive bibliography at the end of the work provides an insight into a lively discussion process within the movement that is still far from complete. A briefly annotated differentiation of terms serves as an overview of the most important meanings of Torah used in the Messianic Jewish movement. Following this preliminary work, the field study is presented. A description of the research field and methodological reflections precede the interviews. In the interviews, the associations with the term Torah are first recorded and the conceptual meaning and use clarified. This already reveals some serious differences. The theological positions and understandings of Torah are presented with the biographical context and main field of influence, and the most important formative influences are named. The points on which they all agree are noted first, as they serve as a common basis. All study the written Torah and consider it, as well as the rest of the Tanakh and the writings of the New Testament in their present form, to be divinely inspired and authoritative. All have found a positive approach to the Torah according to their own definition of the term. For all of them, the written Torah and the Tanakh point to Yeshua. All agree that Yeshua did not abrogate the Torah, but fulfilled it. And all feel a responsibility as a Jew to the Torah in some way. With regard to keeping commandments, all say that no one can earn their way to heaven by doing so. G-d's faithfulness to His promises to Israel is affirmed by all, but whether the new covenant in Yeshua superseded the old covenant of Mt. Sinai, or whether it is simply added to the already existing covenant of Sinai, whether ritual commandments are to continue to be kept after Yeshua's death and resurrection and the destruction of the Temple, whether the commandments aiming at separation from the nations should continue to be kept, whether and under what conditions rabbinic halacha should be followed and what individuals do and teach in their families and communities - all this is discussed interview by interview. It becomes clear how different ways of reading and weighting key scriptures produce different positions. Just as the diversity of positions in relation to the Torah already suggests, the interview partners are divided on the question of a Messianic Jewish Halacha. But here too, the term halacha is interpreted differently by the representatives. At the end of the field study, the attempts to produce Messianic Jewish Halacha and the problems and points of criticism expressed by other interviewees are explained. The work concludes with a theological framework able to contain all the different positions and relationships to the Torah and some starting points for a possible Messianic Jewish hermeneutic theology of the Torah.
Arbeit, Religion, Ruf
(2021)
Die Arbeit als Dienstmädchen stellte im Europa des 19. Jahrhunderts die weitverbreitetste Erwerbstätigkeit von Frauen dar. Oft erwies sie sich als die einzige Möglichkeit, trotz mangelnder Schulbildung und fehlender beruflicher Qualifikationen einen Lebensunterhalt zu bestreiten. In der Regel bewarben sich junge Mädchen, die vor der Gründung eines eigenen Haushalts Geld verdienen wollten. Aber auch ältere Frauen, die unverheiratet blieben, waren teils ihr Leben lang auf den Beruf als Dienstbotin angewiesen.
In den jüdischen Bürgerhaushalten der Niederlande, insbesondere in den zu dieser Zeit blühenden jüdischen Gemeinden in Amsterdam und anderen Großstädten, sah dies nicht anders aus. Auch dort putzten, kochten und stickten Dienstmädchen. Sie nahmen sich der Kindererziehung an und interagierten mit KollegInnen und ArbeitgeberInnen. Vor allem wegen eines Mangels an schriftlichen Quellen ist bisher jedoch wenig über dieses Kapitel jüdischer und weiblicher Erwerbsgeschichte bekannt.
Die vorliegende Studie wirft mit Hilfe von Stellenanzeigen für und von jüdischen Dienstmädchen Licht auf diese Berufsgruppe in den Jahren zwischen 1894 und 1925. Es wird ein Korpus von 540 Inseraten aus der vielgelesenen niederländischen Wochenzeitung Nieuw Israelietisch Weekblad diskursanalytisch untersucht, was neue Erkenntnisse über Leben und Arbeit der Dienstbotinnen zu Tage fördert. Die Anzeigen thematisieren sowohl das gesellschaftliche Ansehen der Frauen, ihre Aufgaben, Qualifikationen und finanziellen Ansprüche sowie ihre Religiosität. Durch einen Vergleich von Anzeigen aus drei Jahrzehnten kann die Studie aufzeigen, wie sich Einstellungen gegenüber dem Dienstmädchenberuf veränderten und sowohl Angestellte als auch ArbeitgeberInnen im Laufe der Zeit neue Maßstäbe an die häusliche Arbeit anlegten.