Refine
Year of publication
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (1038) (remove)
Keywords
- Arabidopsis thaliana (17)
- Klimawandel (13)
- climate change (12)
- Arabidopsis (10)
- Biosensor (9)
- Evolution (9)
- Modellierung (9)
- Transkriptionsfaktoren (9)
- metabolism (9)
- Ökologie (9)
Institute
- Institut für Biochemie und Biologie (1038) (remove)
Hantaviruses (HVs) are a group of zoonotic viruses that infect human beings primarily through aerosol transmission of rodent excreta and urine samplings. HVs are classified geographically into: Old World HVs (OWHVs) that are found in Europe and Asia, and New World HVs (NWHVs) that are observed in the Americas. These different strains can cause severe hantavirus diseases with pronounced renal syndrome or severe cardiopulmonary system distress. HVs can be extremely lethal, with NWHV infections reaching up to 40 % mortality rate. HVs are known to generate epidemic outbreaks in many parts of the world including Germany, which has seen periodic HV infections over the past decade. HV has a trisegmented genome. The small segment (S) encodes the nucleocapsid protein (NP), the middle segment (M) encodes the glycoproteins (GPs) Gn and Gc which forms up to tetramers and primarily monomers \& dimers upon independent expression respectively and large segment (L) encodes RNA dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp). Interactions between these viral proteins are crucial in providing mechanistic insights into HV virion development. Despite best efforts, there continues to be lack of quantification of these associations in living cells. This is required in developing the mechanistic models for HV viral assembly. This dissertation focuses on three key questions pertaining to the initial steps of virion formation that primarily involves the GPs and NP.
The research investigations in this work were completed using Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy (FCS) approaches. FCS is frequently used in assessing the biophysical features of bio-molecules including protein concentration and diffusion dynamics and circumvents the requirement of protein overexpression. FCS was primarily applied in this thesis to evaluate protein multimerization, at single cell resolution.
The first question addressed which GP spike formation model proposed by Hepojoki et al.(2010) appropriately describes the evidence in living cells. A novel in cellulo assay was developed to evaluate the amount of fluorescently labelled and unlabeled GPs upon co-expression. The results clearly showed that Gn and Gc initially formed a heterodimeric Gn:Gc subunit. This sub-unit then multimerizes with congruent Gn:Gc subunits to generate the final GP spike. Based on these interactions, models describing the formation of GP complex (with multiple GP spike subunits) were additionally developed.
HV GP assembly primarily takes place in the Golgi apparatus (GA) of infected cells. Interestingly, NWHV GPs are hypothesized to assemble at the plasma membrane (PM). This led to the second research question in this thesis, in which a systematic comparison between OWHV and NWHV GPs was conducted to validate this hypothesis. Surprisingly, GP localization at the PM was congruently observed with OWHV and NWHV GPs. Similar results were also discerned with OWHV and NWHV GP localization in the absence of cytoskeletal factors that regulate HV trafficking in cells.
The final question focused on quantifying the NP-GP interactions and understanding their influence of NP and GP multimerization. Gc mutlimers were detected in the presence of NP and complimented by the presence of localized regions of high NP-Gc interactions in the perinuclear region of living cells. Gc-CT domain was shown to influence NP-Gc associations. Gn, on the other hand, formed up to tetrameric complexes, independent from the presence of NP.
The results in this dissertation sheds light on the initial steps of HV virion formation by quantifying homo and heterotypic interactions involving NP and GPs, which otherwise are very difficult to perform. Finally, the in cellulo methodologies implemented in this work can be potentially extended to understand other key interactions involved in HV virus assembly.
Pichia pastoris (syn. Komagataella phaffi) is a distinguished expression system widely used in industrial production processes. Recent molecular research has focused on numerous approaches to increase recombinant protein yield in P. pastoris. For example, the design of expression vectors and synthetic genetic elements, gene copy number optimization, or co-expression of helper proteins
(transcription factors, chaperones, etc.). However, high clonal variability of transformants and low screening throughput have hampered significant success.
To enhance screening capacities, display-based methodologies inherit the potential for efficient isolation of producer clones via fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). Therefore, this study focused on developing a novel clone selection method that is based on the non-covalent attachment of Fab fragments on the P. pastoris cell surface to be applicable for FACS.
Initially, a P. pastoris display system was developed, which is a prerequisite for the surface capture of secreted Fabs. A Design of Experiments approach was applied to analyze the influence of various genetic elements on antibody fragment display. The combined P. pastoris formaldehyde dehydrogenase promoter (PFLD1), Saccharomyces cerevisiae invertase 2 signal peptide (ScSUC2), - agglutinin (ScSAG1) anchor protein, and the ARS of Kluyveromyces lactis (panARS) conferred highest display levels.
Subsequently, eight single-chain variable fragments (scFv) specific for the constant part of the Fab heavy or light chain were individually displayed in P. pastoris. Among the tested scFvs, the anti-human CH1 IgG domain scFv allowed the most efficient Fab capture detected by flow cytometry.
Irrespective of the Fab sequence, exogenously added as well as simultaneously secreted Fabs were successfully captured on the cell surface. Furthermore, Fab secretion capacities were shown to correlate to the level of surface-bound Fabs as demonstrated for characterized producer clones.
Flow-sorted clones presenting high amounts of Fabs showed an increase in median Fab titers (factor of 21 to 49) compared to unsorted clones when screened in deep-well plates. For selected candidates, improved functional Fab yields of sorted cells vs. unsorted cells were confirmed in an upscaled shake flask production. Since the scFv capture matrix was encoded on an episomal plasmid with inherently unstable autonomously replicating sequences (ARS), efficient plasmid curing was observed after removing the selective pressure. Hence, sorted clones could be immediately used for production without the need to modify the expression host or vector. The resulting switchable display/secretion system provides a streamlined approach for the isolation of Fab producers and subsequent Fab production.
Development of electrochemical antibody-based and enzymatic assays for mycotoxin analysis in food
(2023)
Electrochemical methods are promising to meet the demand for easy-to-use devices monitoring key parameters in the food industry. Many companies run own lab procedures for mycotoxin analysis, but it is a major goal to simplify the analysis. The enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay using horseradish peroxidase as enzymatic label, together with 3,3',5,5' tetramethylbenzidine (TMB)/H2O2 as substrates allows sensitive mycotoxin detection with optical detection methods. For the miniaturization of the detection step, an electrochemical system for mycotoxin analysis was developed. To this end, the electrochemical detection of TMB was studied by cyclic voltammetry on different screen-printed electrodes (carbon and gold) and at different pH values (pH 1 and pH 4). A stable electrode reaction, which is the basis for the further construction of the electrochemical detection system, could be achieved at pH 1 on gold electrodes. An amperometric detection method for oxidized TMB, using a custom-made flow cell for screen-printed electrodes, was established and applied for a competitive magnetic bead-based immunoassay for the mycotoxin ochratoxin A. A limit of detection of 150 pM (60 ng/L) could be obtained and the results were verified with optical detection. The applicability of the magnetic bead-based immunoassay was tested in spiked beer using a handheld potentiostat connected via Bluetooth to a smartphone for amperometric detection allowing to quantify ochratoxin A down to 1.2 nM (0.5 µg/L).
Based on the developed electrochemical detection system for TMB, the applicability of the approach was demonstrated with a magnetic bead-based immunoassay for the ergot alkaloid, ergometrine. Under optimized assay conditions a limit of detection of 3 nM (1 µg/L) was achieved and in spiked rye flour samples ergometrine levels in a range from 25 to 250 µg/kg could be quantified. All results were verified with optical detection. The developed electrochemical detection method for TMB gives great promise for the detection of TMB in many other HRP-based assays.
A new sensing approach, based on an enzymatic electrochemical detection system for the mycotoxin fumonisin B1 was established using an Aspergillus niger fumonisin amine oxidase (AnFAO). AnFAO was produced recombinantly in E. coli as maltose-binding protein fusion protein and catalyzes the oxidative deamination of fumonisins, producing hydrogen peroxide. It was found that AnFAO has a high storage and temperature stability. The enzyme was coupled covalently to magnetic particles, and the enzymatically produced H2O2 in the reaction with fumonisin B1 was detected amperometrically in a flow injection system using Prussian blue/carbon electrodes and the custom-made wall-jet flow cell. Fumonisin B1 could be quantified down to 1.5 µM (≈ 1 mg/L). The developed system represents a new approach to detect mycotoxins using enzymes and electrochemical methods.
Potato FLC-like and SVP-like proteins jointly control growth and distinct developmental processes
(2023)
Based on worldwide consumption, Solanum tuberosum L. (potato) is the most important non-grain food crop. Potato has two ways of stable propagation: sexually via flowering and vegetatively via tuberization. Remarkably, these two developmental processes are controlled by similar molecular regulators and mechanisms. Given that FLC and SVP genes act as key flowering regulators in the model species Arabidopsis and in various other crop species, this study aimed at identifying FLC and SVP homologs in potato and investigating their roles in the regulation of plant development, with a particular focus on flowering and tuberization. Our analysis demonstrated that there are five FLC-like and three SVP like proteins encoded in the potato genome. The expression profiles of StFLCs and StSVPs throughout potato development and the detected interactions between their proteins indicate tissue specificity of the individual genes and distinct roles of a variety of putative protein complexes. In particular, we discovered that StFLC-D, as well as StFLC-B, StSVP-A, and StSVP-B play a complex role in the regulation of flowering time, as not only increased but also decreased levels of their transcripts promote earlier flowering. Most importantly, StFLC-D has a marked impact on tuberization under non-inductive conditions and susceptibility to temperature-induced tuber malformation, also known as second growth. Plants with decreased levels of StFLC-D demonstrated a strong ability to produce tubers under long days and appeared to be insensitive to temperature-induced second growth. Lastly, our data also suggests that StFLCs and StSVPs may be involved in the nitrogen-dependent regulation of potato development. Taken together, this study highlights the functional importance of StFLC and StSVP genes in the regulation of distinct developmental processes in potato.
Movement is a mechanism that shapes biodiversity patterns across spatialtemporal scales. Thereby, the movement process affects species interactions, population dynamics and community composition. In this thesis, I disentangled the effects of movement on the biodiversity of zooplankton ranging from the individual to the community level. On the individual movement level, I used video-based analysis to explore the implication of movement behavior on preypredator interactions. My results showed that swimming behavior was of great importance as it determined their survival in the face of predation. The findings also additionally highlighted the relevance of the defense status/morphology of prey, as it not only affected the prey-predator relationship by the defense itself but also by plastic movement behavior. On the community movement level, I used a field mesocosm experiment to explore the role of dispersal (time i.e., from the egg bank into the water body and space i.e., between water bodies) in shaping zooplankton metacommunities. My results revealed that priority effects and taxon-specific dispersal limitation influenced community composition. Additionally, different modes of dispersal also generated distinct community structures. The egg bank and biotic vectors (i.e. mobile links) played significant roles in the colonization of newly available habitat patches. One crucial aspect that influences zooplankton species after arrival in new habitats is the local environmental conditions. By using common garden experiments, I assessed the performance of zooplankton communities in their home vs away environments in a group of ponds embedded within an agricultural landscape. I identified environmental filtering as a driving factor as zooplankton communities from individual ponds developed differently in their home and away environments. On the individual species level, there was no consistent indication of local adaptation. For some species, I found a higher abundance/fitness in their home environment, but for others, the opposite was the case, and some cases were indifferent.
Overall, the thesis highlights the links between movement and biodiversity patterns, ranging from the individual active movement to the community level.
Life on Earth is diverse and ranges from unicellular organisms to multicellular creatures like humans. Although there are theories about how these organisms might have evolved, we understand little about how ‘life’ started from molecules. Bottom-up synthetic biology aims to create minimal cells by combining different modules, such as compartmentalization, growth, division, and cellular communication.
All living cells have a membrane that separates them from the surrounding aqueous medium and helps to protect them. In addition, all eukaryotic cells have organelles that are enclosed by intracellular membranes. Each cellular membrane is primarily made of a lipid bilayer with membrane proteins. Lipids are amphiphilic molecules that assemble into molecular bilayers consisting of two leaflets. The hydrophobic chains of the lipids in the two leaflets face each other, and their hydrophilic headgroups face the aqueous surroundings. Giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) are model membrane systems that form large compartments with a size of many micrometers and enclosed by a single lipid bilayer. The size of GUVs is comparable to the size of cells, making them good membrane models which can be studied using an optical microscope. However, after the initial preparation, GUV membranes lack membrane proteins which have to be reconstituted into these membranes by subsequent preparation steps. Depending on the protein, it can be either attached via anchor lipids to one of the membrane leaflets or inserted into the lipid bilayer via its transmembrane domains.
The first step is to prepare the GUVs and then expose them to an exterior solution with proteins. Various protocols have been developed for the initial preparation of GUVs. For the second step, the GUVs can be exposed to a bulk solution of protein or can be trapped in a microfluidic device and then supplied with the protein solution. To minimize the amount of solution and for more precise measurements, I have designed a microfluidic device that has a main channel, and several dead-end side channels that are perpendicular to the main channel. The GUVs are trapped in the dead-end channels. This design exchanges the solution around the GUVs via diffusion from the main channel, thus shielding the GUVs from the flow within the main channel. This device has a small volume of just 2.5 μL, can be used without a pump and can be combined with a confocal microscope, enabling uninterrupted imaging of the GUVs during the experiments. I used this device for most of the experiments on GUVs that are discussed in this thesis.
In the first project of the thesis, a lipid mixture doped with an anchor lipid was used that can bind to a histidine chain (referred to as His-tag(ged) or 6H) via the metal cation Ni2+. This method is widely used for the biofunctionalization of GUVs by attaching proteins without a transmembrane domain. Fluorescently labeled His-tags which are bound to a membrane can be observed in a confocal microscope. Using the same lipid mixture, I prepared the GUVs with different protocols and investigated the membrane composition of the resulting GUVs by evaluating the amount of fluorescently labeled His-tagged molecules bound to their membranes. I used the microfluidic device described above to expose the outer leaflet of the vesicle to a constant concentration of the His-tagged molecules. Two fluorescent molecules with a His-tag were studied and compared: green fluorescent protein (6H-GFP) and fluorescein isothiocyanate (6H-FITC). Although the quantum yield in solution is similar for both molecules, the brightness of the membrane-bound 6H-GFP is higher than the brightness of the membrane-bound 6H-FITC. The observed difference in the brightness reveals that the fluorescence of the 6H-FITC is quenched by the anchor lipid via the Ni2+ ion. Furthermore, my measurements also showed that the fluorescence intensity of the membranebound His-tagged molecules depends on microenvironmental factors such as pH. For both 6H-GFP and 6H-FITC, the interaction with the membrane is quantified by evaluating the equilibrium dissociation constant. The membrane fluorescence is measured as a function of the fluorophores’ molar concentration. Theoretical analysis of these data leads to the equilibrium dissociation constants of (37.5 ± 7.5) nM for 6H-GFP and (18.5 ± 3.7) nM for 6H-FITC.
The anchor lipid mentioned previously used the metal cation Ni2+ to mediate the bond between the anchor lipid and the His-tag. The Ni2+ ion can be replaced by other transition metal ions. Studies have shown that Co3+ forms the strongest bonds with the His-tags attached to proteins. In these studies, strong oxidizing agents were used to oxidize the Co2+ mediated complex with the His-tagged protein to a Co3+ mediated complex. This procedure puts the proteins at risk of being oxidized as well. In this thesis, the vesicles were first prepared with anchor lipids without any metal cation. The Co3+ was added to these anchor lipids and finally the His-tagged protein was added to the GUVs to form the Co3+ mediated bond. This system was also established using the microfluidic device.
The different preparation procedures of GUVs usually lead to vesicles with a spherical morphology. On the other hand, many cell organelles have a more complex architecture with a non spherical topology. One fascinating example is provided by the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) which is made of a continuous membrane and extends throughout the cell in the form of tubes and sheets. The tubes are connected by three-way junctions and form a tubular network of irregular polygons. The formation and maintenance of these reticular networks requires membrane proteins that hydrolyize guanosine triphosphate (GTP). One of these membrane proteins is atlastin. In this thesis, I reconstituted the atlastin protein in GUV membranes using detergent-assisted reconstitution protocols to insert the proteins directly into lipid bilayers.
This thesis focuses on protein reconstitution by binding His-tagged proteins to anchor lipids and by detergent-assisted insertion of proteins with transmembrane domains. It also provides the design of a microfluidic device that can be used in various experiments, one example is the evaluation of the equilibrium dissociation constant for membrane-protein interactions. The results of this thesis will help other researchers to understand the protocols for preparing GUVs, to reconstitute proteins in GUVs, and to perform experiments using the microfluidic device. This knowledge should be beneficial for the long-term goal of combining the different modules of synthetic biology to make a minimal cell.
Predator-forager interactions are a major factor in evolutionary adaptation of many species, as predators need to gain energy by consuming prey species, and foragers needs to avoid the worst fate of mortality while still consuming resources for energetic gains. In this evolutionary arms race, the foragers have constantly evolved anti-predator behaviours (e.g. foraging activity changes). To describe all these complex changes, researchers developed the framework of the landscape of fear, that is, the spatio-temporal variation of perceived predation risk. This concept simplifies all the involved ecological processes into one framework, by integrating animal biology and distribution with habitat characteristics. Researchers can then evaluate the perception of predation risk in prey species, what are the behavioural responses of the prey and, therefore, understand the cascading effects of landscapes of fear at the resource levels (tri-trophic effects). Although tri-trophic effects are well studied at the predator-prey interaction level, little is known on how the forager-resource interactions are part of the overall cascading effects of landscapes of fear, despite the changes of forager feeding behaviour - that occur with perceived predation risk - affecting directly the level of the resources.
This thesis aimed to evaluate the cascading effects of the landscape of fear on biodiversity of resources, and how the feeding behaviour and movement of foragers shaped the final resource species composition (potential coexistence mechanisms). We studied the changes caused by landscapes of fear on wild and captive rodent communities and evaluated: the cascading effects of different landscapes of fear on a tri-trophic system (I), the effects of fear on a forager’s movement patterns and dietary preferences (II) and cascading effects of different types of predation risk (terrestrial versus avian, III).
In Chapter I, we applied a novel measure to evaluate the cascading effects of fear at the level of resources, by quantifying the diversity of resources left after the foragers gave-up on foraging (diversity at the giving-up density). We tested the measure at different spatial levels (local and regional) and observed that with decreased perceived predation risk, the density and biodiversity of resources also decreased. Foragers left a very dissimilar community of resources based on perceived risk and resources functional traits, and therefore acted as an equalising mechanism.
In Chapter II, we wanted to understand further the decision-making processes of rodents in different landscapes of fear, namely, in which resource species rodents decided to forage on (based on three functional traits: size, nutrients and shape) and how they moved depending on perceived predation risk. In safe landscapes, individuals increased their feeding activity and movements and despite the increased costs, they visited more often patches that were further away from their central-place. Despite a preference for the bigger resources regardless of risk, when perceived predation risk was low, individuals changed their preference to fat-rich resources.
In Chapter III, we evaluated the cascading effects of two different types of predation risk in rodents: terrestrial (raccoon) versus avian predation risk. Raccoon presence or absence did not alter the rodents feeding behaviour in different landscapes of fear. Rodent’s showed risk avoidance behaviours towards avian predators (spatial risk avoidance), but not towards raccoons (lack of temporal risk avoidance).
By analysing the effects of fear in tri-trophic systems, we were able to deepen the knowledge of how non-consumptive effects of predators affect the behaviour of foragers, and quantitatively measure the cascading effects at the level of resources with a novel measure. Foragers are at the core of the ecological processes and responses to the landscape of fear, acting as variable coexistence agents for resource species depending on perceived predation risk. This newly found measures and knowledge can be applied to more trophic chains, and inform researchers on biodiversity patterns originating from landscapes of fear.
Increasing demand for food, healthcare, and transportation arising from the growing world population is accompanied by and driving global warming challenges due to the rise of the atmospheric CO2 concentration. Industrialization for human needs has been increasingly releasing CO2 into the atmosphere for the last century or more. In recent years, the possibility of recycling CO2 to stabilize the atmospheric CO2 concentration and combat rising temperatures has gained attention. Thus, using CO2 as the feedstock to address future world demands is the ultimate solution while controlling the rapid climate change. Valorizing CO2 to produce activated and stable one-carbon feedstocks like formate and methanol and further upgrading them to industrial microbial processes to replace unsustainable feedstocks would be crucial for a future biobased circular economy. However, not all microbes can grow on formate as a feedstock, and those microbes that can grow are not well established for industrial processes.
S. cerevisiae is one of the industrially well-established microbes, and it is a significant contributor to bioprocess industries. However, it cannot grow on formate as a sole carbon and energy source. Thus, engineering S. cerevisiae to grow on formate could potentially pave the way to sustainable biomass and value-added chemicals production.
The Reductive Glycine Pathway (RGP), designed as the aerobic twin of the anaerobic Reductive Acetyl-CoA pathway, is an efficient formate and CO2 assimilation pathway. The RGP comprises of the glycine synthesis module (Mis1p, Gcv1p, Gcv2p, Gcv3p, and Lpd1p), the glycine to serine conversion module (Shmtp), the pyruvate synthesis module (Cha1p), and the energy supply module (Fdh1p). The RGP requires formate and elevated CO2 levels to operate the glycine synthesis module. In this study, I established the RGP in the yeast system using growth-coupled selection strategies to achieve formate and CO2-dependent biomass formation in aerobic conditions.
Firstly, I constructed serine biosensor strains by disrupting the native serine and glycine biosynthesis routes in the prototrophic S288c and FL100 yeast strains and insulated serine, glycine, and one-carbon metabolism from the central metabolic network. These strains cannot grow on glucose as the sole carbon source but require the supply of serine or glycine to complement the engineered auxotrophies. Using growth as a readout, I employed these strains as selection hosts to establish the RGP. Initially, to achieve this, I engineered different serine-hydroxymethyltransferases in the genome of serine biosensor strains for efficient glycine to serine conversion. Then, I implemented the glycine synthesis module of the RGP in these strains for the glycine and serine synthesis from formate and CO2. I successfully conducted Adaptive Laboratory Evolution (ALE) using these strains, which yielded a strain capable of glycine and serine biosynthesis from formate and CO2. Significant growth improvements from 0.0041 h-1 to 0.03695 h-1 were observed during ALE. To validate glycine and serine synthesis, I conducted carbon tracing experiments with 13C formate and 13CO2, confirming that more than 90% of glycine and serine biosynthesis in the evolved strains occurs via the RGP. Interestingly, labeling data also revealed that 10-15% of alanine was labelled, indicating pyruvate synthesis from the formate-derived serine using native serine deaminase (Cha1p) activity. Thus, RGP contributes to a small pyruvate pool which is converted to alanine without any selection pressure for pyruvate synthesis from formate. Hence, this data confirms the activity of all three modules of RGP even in the presence of glucose. Further, ALE in glucose limiting conditions did not improve pyruvate flux via the RGP.
Growth characterization of these strains showed that the best growth rates were achieved in formate concentrations between 25 mM to 300 mM. Optimum growth required 5% CO2, and dropped when the CO2 concentration was reduced from 5% to 2.5%.
Whole-genome sequencing of these evolved strains revealed mutations in genes that encode Gdh1p, Pet9p, and Idh1p. These enzymes might influence intracellular NADPH, ATP, and NADH levels, indicating adjustment to meet the energy demand of the RGP. I reverse-engineered the GDH1 truncation mutation on unevolved serine biosensor strains and reproduced formate dependent growth. To elucidate the effect of the GDH1 mutation on formate assimilation, I reintroduced this mutation in the S288c strain and conducted carbon-tracing experiments to compared formate assimilation between WT and ∆gdh1 mutant strains. Comparatively, enhanced formate assimilation was recorded in the ∆gdh1 mutant strain.
Although the 13C carbon tracing experiments confirmed the activity of all three modules of the RGP, the overall pyruvate flux via the RGP might be limited by the supply of reducing power. Hence, in a different approach, I overexpressed the formate dehydrogenase (Fdh1p) for energy supply and serine deaminase (Cha1p) for active pyruvate synthesis in the S288c parental strain and established growth on formate and serine without glucose in the medium. Further reengineering and evolution of this strain with a consistent energy, and formate-derived serine supply for pyruvate synthesis, is essential to achieve complete formatotrophic growth in the yeast system.
Transposable elements (TEs) are loci that can replicate and multiply within the genome of their host. Within the host, TEs through transposition are responsible for variation on genomic architecture and gene regulation across all vertebrates. Genome assemblies have increased in numbers in recent years. However, to explore in deep the variations within different genomes, such as SNPs (single nucleotide polymorphism), INDELs (Insertion-deletion), satellites and transposable elements, we need high-quality genomes. Studies of molecular markers in the past 10 years have limitations to correlate with biological differences because molecular markers rely on the accuracy of the genomic resources. This has generated that a substantial part of the studies of TE in recent years have been on high quality genomic resources such as Drosophila, zebrafinch and maize. As testudine have a slow mutation rate lower only to crocodilians, with more than 300 species, adapted to different environments all across the globe, the testudine clade can help us to study variation. Here we propose Testudines as a clade to study variation and the abundance of TE on different species that diverged a long time ago. We investigated the genomic diversity of sea turtles, identifying key genomic regions associated to gene family duplication, specific expansion of particular TE families for Dermochelyidae and that are important for phenotypic differentiation, the impact of environmental changes on their populations, and the dynamics of TEs within different lineages. In chapter 1, we identify that despite high levels of genome synteny within sea turtles, we identified that regions of reduced collinearity and microchromosomes showed higher concentrations of multicopy gene families, as well as genetic distances between species, indicating their potential importance as sources of variation underlying phenotypic differentiation. We found that differences in the ecological niches occupied by leatherback and green turtles have led to contrasting evolutionary paths for their olfactory receptor genes. We identified in leatherback turtles a long-term low population size. Nonetheless, we identify no correlation between the regions of reduced collinearity with abundance of TEs or an accumulation of a particular TE group. In chapter 2, we identified that sea turtle genomes contain a significant proportion of TEs, with differences in TE abundance between species, and the discovery of a recent expansion of Penelope-like elements (PLEs) in the highly conserved sea turtle genome provides new insights into the dynamics of TEs within Testudines. In chapter 3, we compared the proportion of TE across the Testudine clade, and we identified that the proportion of transposable elements within the clade is stable, regardless of the quality of the assemblies. However, we identified that the proportion of TEs orders has correlation with genome quality depending of their expanded abundancy. For retrotransposon, a highly abundant element for this clade, we identify no correlation. However, for DNA elements a rarer element on this clade, correlate with the quality of the assemblies.
Here we confirm that high-quality genomes are fundamental for the study of transposable element evolution and the conservation within the clade. The detection and abundance of specific orders of TEs are influenced by the quality of the genomes. We identified that a reduction in the population size on D. coriacea had left signals of long-term low population sizes on their genomes. On the same note we identified an expansion of TE on D. coriacea, not present in any other member of the available genomes of Testudines, strongly suggesting that it is a response of deregulation of TE on their genomes as consequences of the low population sizes.
Here we have identified important genomic regions and gene families for phenotypic differentiation and highlighted the impact of environmental changes on the populations of sea turtles. We stated that accurate classification and analysis of TE families are important and require high-quality genome assemblies. Using TE analysis we manage to identify differences in highly syntenic species. These findings have significant implications for conservation and provide a foundation for further research into genome evolution and gene function in turtles and other vertebrates. Overall, this study contributes to our understanding of evolutionary change and adaptation mechanisms.
Monoklonale Antikörper (mAK) sind eines der wichtigsten Biomoleküle für die Umweltanalytik und die medizinische Diagnostik. Für die Detektion von Mikroorganismen bilden sie die Grundlage für ein schnelles und präzises Testverfahren. Bis heute gibt es, aufgrund des hohen zeitlichen und materiellen Aufwandes und der unspezifischen Immunisierungsstrategien, nur wenige mAK, die spezifisch Mikroorganismen erkennen.
Zu diesem Zweck sollte ein anwendbares Verfahren für die Generierung von mAK gegen Mikroorganismen entwickelt werden, welches anhand von Escherichia coli O157:H7 und Legionella pneumophila validiert wurde. In dieser Dissertation konnten neue Oberflächenstrukturen auf den Mikroorganismen mittels vergleichender Genomanalysen und in silico Epitopanalysen identifiziert werden. Diese wurden in das Virushüllprotein VP1 integriert und für eine gezielte Immunisierungsstrategie verwendet. Für die Bestimmung antigenspezifischer antikörperproduzierender Hybridome wurde ein Immunfärbeprotokoll entwickelt und etabliert, um die Hybridome im Durchflusszytometer zu sortieren.
In der vorliegenden Studie konnten für E. coli O157:H7 insgesamt 53 potenzielle Proteinkandidaten und für L. pneumophila 38 Proteine mithilfe der bioinformatischen Analyse identifiziert werden. Fünf verschiedene potenzielle Epitope wurden für E. coli O157:H7 und drei verschiedenen für L. pneumophila ausgewählt und für die Immunisierung mit chimären VP1 verwendet. Alle Immunseren zeigten eine antigenspezifische Immunantwort. Aus den nachfolgend generierten Hybridomzellen konnten mehrere Antikörperkandidaten gewonnen werden, welche in Charakterisierungsstudien eine starke Bindung zu E. coli O157:H7 bzw. L. pneumophila vorwiesen. Kreuzreaktivitäten zu anderen relevanten Mikroorganismen konnten keine bzw. nur in geringem Maße festgestellt werden.
Folglich konnte der hier beschriebene interdisziplinäre Ansatz zur Generierung spezifischer mAK gegen Mikroorganismen nachweislich spezifische mAK hervorbringen und ist als hocheffizienter Arbeitsablauf für die Herstellung von Antikörpern gegen Mikroorganismen einsetzbar.
In nature, plants often encounter biotic and abiotic stresses, which can cause reduced crop yield and quality, and threaten the nutrition of a growing human population. As heat stress (HS) is one of the main abiotic stresses, and is projected to increase due to global warming, it is necessary to better understand how plants respond and survive under HS. In Arabidopsis thaliana, plants can survive under severe HS if primed by a non-lethal HS, a process called acquisition of thermotolerance. This primed stated can be maintained for several days, and the ability of plants to maintain the primed state is called maintenance of acquired thermotolerance (mATT) or HS memory. According to current research, two Heat shock factors (HSFs) HSFA2 and HSFA3 are known to account for the majority of mATT capability, and there are other HSFs e.g. HSFA1b and HSFA6b in HSF complexes containing HSFA2 and/or HSFA3, however, the roles of these HSFs in HS memory is not clearly understood. Moreover, the mechanism of these HSFs in regulating HS memory is unclear, whether transcriptional machinery e.g. the Mediator complex contributes to transcriptional memory. This work investigates the role of HSFs and Mediator subunits in HS memory in A. thaliana. For the role of HSFs, the interaction between HSFA1b and HSFA2 during HS memory phase was confirmed by in vivo co- immunoprecipitation (Co-IP). HSFA1b, HSFA2, HSFA3 and HSFA6b targeted HS memory-related genes according to DNA affinity purification sequencing (DAP-seq) data, and targets of HSFA1b were confirmed in vivo by chromatin immunoprecipitation qPCR (ChIP-qPCR). The mutant of hsfa6b showed an HS memory deficiency phenotype in mATT survival assay. These data confirmed the role for HSFA2 and HSFA3 in HS memory, and suggest that HSFA1b and HSFA6b also function in HS memory. The Mediator complex functions as an RNA Polymerase II (RNA Pol II) co-regulator, and includes Head, Middle, Tail and Kinase modules. Both MED23 and MED32 belong to the Tail module, and they have a positive role in HS memory. MED23 interacted with HSFA3, as determined by yeast two hybrid (Y2H) and in vivo Co-IP assays. The med23 mutant showed a decreased HS memory phenotype, reduced expression of Type I (sustained expression) memory genes following HS, and reduced accumulation of the memory-associated Tri-methylation of histone H3 lysine 4 (H3K4me3)histone modification at HS memory-related gene loci after HS. MED23 was recruited to HS-inducible memory and non-memory genes after HS, as determined by ChIP-qPCR. The med32
mutant showed a reduced HS memory phenotype, decreased expression of Type I and Type II (hyper-induction) memory genes, and lower accumulation of H3K4me3 at memory gene lociafter HS. However, MED32 did not show interaction with any tested HSF in Y2H or in vivo Co-IP. MED32 regulated the recruitment of RNA Pol II at HS-inducible genes after HS, but was not itself recruited to HS memory genes after HS. These results provided more evidence
that the Mediator subunits MED23 and MED32 regulate HS memory on transcriptional and epigenetic levels. In general, this work provides a better insight into the molecular mechanism of how HSFs and Mediator subunits regulate HS memory in plants and will provide new perspectives to breed crops with improved thermotolerance.
Functional characterization of ROS-responsive genes, ANAC085 and ATR7, in Arabidopsis thaliana
(2023)
Biostimulant SuperFifty based molecular priming to increase plant strength and stress tolerance
(2023)
In times of ongoing biodiversity loss, understanding how communities are structured and what mechanisms and local adaptations underlie the patterns we observe in nature is crucial for predicting how future ecological and anthropogenic changes might affect local and regional biodiversity. Aquatic zooplankton are a group of primary consumers that represent a critical link in the food chain, providing nutrients for the entire food web. Thus, understanding the adaptability and structure of zooplankton communities is essential. In this work, the genetic basis for the different temperature adaptations of two seasonally shifted (i.e., temperature-dependent) occurring freshwater rotifers of a formerly cryptic species complex (Brachionus calyciflorus) was investigated to understand the overall genetic diversity and evolutionary scenario for putative adaptations to different temperature regimes. Furthermore, this work aimed to clarify to what extent the different temperature adaptations may represent a niche partitioning process thus enabling co-existence. The findings were then embedded in a metacommunity context to understand how zooplankton communities assemble in a kettle hole metacommunity located in the northeastern German "Uckermark" and which underlying processes contribute to the biodiversity patterns we observe. Using a combined approach of newly generated mitochondrial resources (genomes/cds) and the analysis of a candidate gene (Heat Shock Protein 40kDa) for temperature adaptation, I showed that the global representatives of B. calyciflorus s.s.. are genetically more similar than B. fernandoi (average pairwise nucleotide diversity: 0.079 intraspecific vs. 0.257 interspecific) indicating that both species carry different standing genetic variation. In addition to differential expression in the thermotolerant B. calyciflorus s.s. and thermosensitive B. fernandoi, the HSP 40kDa also showed structural variation with eleven fixed and six positively selected sites, some of which are located in functional areas of the protein. The estimated divergence time of ~ 25-29 Myr combined with the fixed sites and a prevalence of ancestral amino acids in B. calyciflorus s.s. indicate that B. calyciflorus s.s. remained in the ancestral niche, while B. fernandoi partitioned into a new niche. The comparison of mitochondrial and nuclear markers (HPS 40kDa, ITS1, COI) revealed a hybridisation event between the two species. However, as hybridisation between the two species is rare, it can be concluded that the temporally isolated niches (i.e., seasonal-shifted occurrence) they inhabit based on their different temperature preferences most likely represent a pre-zygotic isolation mechanism that allows sympatric occurrence while maintaining species boundaries. To determine the processes underlying zooplankton community assembly, a zooplankton metacommunity comprising 24 kettle holes was sampled over a two-year period. Active (i.e., water samples) and dormant communities (i.e., dormant eggs hatched from sediment) were identified using a two-fragment DNA metabarcoding approach (COI and 18S). Species richness and diversity as well as community composition were analysed considering spatial, temporal and environmental parameters. The analysis revealed that environmental filtering based on parameters such as pH, size and location of the habitat patch (i.e., kettle hole) and surrounding field crops largely determined zooplankton community composition (explained variance: Bray-Curtis dissimilarities: 10.5%; Jaccard dissimilarities: 12.9%), indicating that adaptation to a particular habitat is a key feature of zooplankton species in this system. While the spatial configuration of the kettle holes played a minor role (explained variance: Bray-Curtis dissimilarities: 2.8% and Jaccard dissimilarities: 5.5%), the individual kettle hole sites had a significant influence on the community composition. This suggests monopolisation/priority effects (i.e., dormant communities) of certain species in individual kettle holes. As environmental filtering is the dominating process structuring zooplankton communities, this system could be significantly influenced by future land-use change, pollution and climate change.
Dielektrophorese ist die Manipulation polarisierbarer Partikel durch inhomogene elektrische Wechselfelder. In dieser Arbeit wurden drei verschiedene Enzyme durch Dielektrophorese immobilisiert und anschließend hinsichtlich ihrer katalytischen Aktivität untersucht: Meerrettichperoxidase, Cholinoxidase aus Alcaligenes sp. und Glucoseoxidase aus Aspergillus niger. Die Immobilisierung erfolgte durch Dielektrophorese auf nano-Elektrodenarrays aus Wolfram-Zylindern mit 500 nm Durchmesser oder aus Titannitrid-Ringen mit 20 nm Breite. Die Immobilisierung der Enzyme konnte fluoreszenzmikroskopisch entweder anhand der intrinsischen Fluoreszenz oder aufgrund einer Fluoreszenzmarkierung vor oder nach der Immobilisierung für alle getesteten Enzyme nachgewiesen werden. Die Messung der Enzymaktivität erfolgte quantitativ durch den direkten oder indirekten Nachweis des gebildeten Produktes oder, im Falle der Cholinoxidase, durch Beobachtung der intrinsischen Fluoreszenz des Cofaktors FAD, die vom Oxidationszustand dieses Enzyms abhängt. Für die Meerrettichperoxidase konnte so eine hohe erhaltene Enzymaktivität nach der Immobilisierung nachgewiesen werden. Die Aktivität der permanent immobilisierten Fraktion der Meerrettichperoxidase entsprach bis zu 47 % der höchstmöglichen Aktivität einer Monolage dieses Enzyms auf den Elektroden des Chips. Diese Aktivität kann als aktive, aber zufällig gegenüber der Oberfläche ausgerichtete Enzymschicht interpretiert werden. Für die permanent immobilisierte Glucoseoxidase wurde nur eine Aktivität entsprechend <1,3 % der Aktivität einer solchen Enzymschicht detektiert, während für die immobilisierte Cholinoxidase gar keine Aktivität nachgewiesen werden konnte. Die Aktivität der durch DEP immobilisierten Enzyme konnte somit quantitativ bestimmt werden. Der Anteil an erhaltener Aktivität hängt dabei stark vom verwendeten Enzym ab.
Biomolecules such as proteins and lipids have vital roles in numerous cellular functions, including biomolecule transport, protein functions, cellular homeostasis and biomembrane integrity. Traditional biochemistry methods do not provide precise information about cellular biomolecule distribution and behavior under native environmental conditions since they are not transferable to live cell samples. Consequently, this can lead to inaccuracies in quantifying biomolecule interactions due to potential complexities arising from the heterogeneity of native biomembranes. To overcome these limitations, minimal invasive microscopic techniques, such as fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy (FFS) in combination with fluorescence proteins (FPs) and fluorescence lipid analogs, have been developed. FFS techniques and membrane property sensors enable the quantification of various parameters, including concentration, dynamics, oligomerization, and interaction of biomolecules in live cell samples.
In this work, several FFS approaches and membrane property sensors were implemented and employed to examine biological processes of diverse context. Multi-color scanning fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy (sFCS) was used the examine protein oligomerization, protein-protein interactions (PPIs) and protein dynamics at the cellular plasma membrane (PM). Additionally, two-color number and brightness (N&B) analysis was extended with the cross-correlation analysis in order to quantify hetero-interactions of proteins in the PM with very slow motion, which would not accessible with sFCS due strong initial photobleaching. Furthermore, two semi-automatic analysis pipelines were designed: spectral Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) analysis to study changes in membrane charge at the inner leaflet of the PM, and spectral generalized polarization (GP) imaging and spectral phasor analysis to monitor changes in membrane fluidity and order.
An important parameter for studying PPIs is molecular brightness, which directly determines oligomerization and can be extracted from FFS data. However, FPs often display complex photophysical transitions, including dark states. Therefore, it is crucial to characterize FPs for their dark-states to ensure reliable oligomerization measurements. In this study, N&B and sFCS analysis were applied to determine photophysical properties of novel green FPs under different conditions (i.e., excitation power and pH) in living cells. The results showed that the new FPs, mGreenLantern (mGL) and Gamillus, exhibited the highest molecular brightness at the cost of lower photostability. The well-established monomeric enhanced green fluorescent protein (mEGFP) remained the best option to investigate PPIs at lower pH, while mGL was best suited for neutral pH, and Gamillus for high pH. These findings provide guidance for selecting an appropriate FP to quantify PPIs via FFS under different environmental conditions.
Next, several biophysical fluorescence microscopy approaches (i.e., sFCS, GP imaging, membrane charge FRET) were employed to monitor changes in lipid-lipid-packing in biomembranes in different biological context. Lipid metabolism in cancer cells is known to support rapid proliferation and metastasis. Therefore, targeting lipid synthesis or membrane integrity holds immense promise as an anticancer strategy. However, the mechanism of action of the novel agent erufosine (EPC3) on membrane stability is not fully under
stood. The present work revealed that EPC3 reduces lipid packing and composition as well as increased membrane fluidity and dynamic, hence, modifies lipid-lipid-interaction. These effects on membrane integrity were likely triggered by modulations in lipid metabolism and membrane organization. In the case of influenza A virus (IAV) infection, regulation of lipid metabolism is crucial for multiple steps in IAV replication and is related to the pathogenicity of IAV. Here, it is shown for the first time that IAV infection triggers a local enrichment of negatively charged lipids at the inner leaflet of the PM, which decreases membrane fluidity and dynamic, as well as increases lipid packing at the assembly site in living cells. This suggests that IAV alters lipid-lipid interactions and organization at the PM. Overall, this work highlights the potential of biophysical techniques as a screening platform for studying membrane properties in living cells at the single-cell level.
Finally, this study addressed remaining questions about the early stage of IAV assembly. The recruitment of matrix protein 1 (M1) and its interaction with other viral surface proteins, hemagglutinin (HA), neuraminidase (NA), and matrix protein 2 (M2), has been a subject of debate due to conflicting results. In this study, different FFS approaches were performed in transfected cells to investigate interactions between IAV proteins themselves and host factors at the PM. FFS measurements revealed that M2 interacts strongly with M1, leading to the translocation of M1 to the PM. This interaction likely took place along the non-canonical pathway, as evidenced by the detection of an interaction between M2 and the host factor LC3-II, leading to the recruitment of LC3-II to the PM. Moreover, weaker interaction was observed between HA and membrane-bound M1, and no interaction between NA and M1. Interestingly, higher oligomeric states of M1 were only detectable in infected cells. These results indicate that M2 initiates virion assembly by recruiting M1 to the PM, which may serve as a platform for further interactions with viral proteins and host factors.
In the present thesis, AC electrokinetic forces, like dielectrophoresis and AC electroosmosis, were demonstrated as a simple and fast method to functionalize the surface of nanoelectrodes with submicrometer sized biological objects. These nanoelectrodes have a cylindrical shape with a diameter of 500 nm arranged in an array of 6256 electrodes. Due to its medical relevance influenza virus as well as anti-influenza antibodies were chosen as a model organism. Common methods to bring antibodies or proteins to biosensor surfaces are complex and time-consuming. In the present work, it was demonstrated that by applying AC electric fields influenza viruses and antibodies can be immobilized onto the nanoelectrodes within seconds without any prior chemical modification of neither the surface nor the immobilized biological object. The distribution of these immobilized objects is not uniform over the entire array, it exhibits a decreasing gradient from the outer row to the inner ones. Different causes for this gradient have been discussed, such as the vortex-shaped fluid motion above the nanoelectrodes generated by, among others, electrothermal fluid flow. It was demonstrated that parts of the accumulated material are permanently immobilized to the electrodes. This is a unique characteristic of the presented system since in the literature the AC electrokinetic immobilization is almost entirely presented as a method just for temporary immobilization. The spatial distribution of the immobilized viral material or the anti-influenza antibodies at the electrodes was observed by either the combination of fluorescence microscopy and deconvolution or by super-resolution microscopy (STED). On-chip immunoassays were performed to examine the suitability of the functionalized electrodes as a potential affinity-based biosensor. Two approaches were pursued: A) the influenza virus as the bio-receptor or B) the influenza virus as the analyte. Different sources of error were eliminated by ELISA and passivation experiments. Hence, the activity of the immobilized object was inspected by incubation with the analyte. This resulted in the successful detection of anti-influenza antibodies by the immobilized viral material. On the other hand, a detection of influenza virus particles by the immobilized anti-influenza antibodies was not possible. The latter might be due to lost activity or wrong orientation of the antibodies. Thus, further examinations on the activity of by AC electric fields immobilized antibodies should follow. When combined with microfluidics and an electrical read-out system, the functionalized chips possess the potential to serve as a rapid, portable, and cost-effective point-of-care (POC) device. This device can be utilized as a basis for diverse applications in diagnosing and treating influenza, as well as various other pathogens.
The global climate crisis is significantly contributing to changing ecosystems, loss of biodiversity and is putting numerous species on the verge of extinction. In principle, many species are able to adapt to changing conditions or shift their habitats to more suitable regions. However, change is progressing faster than some species can adjust, or potential adaptation is blocked and disrupted by direct and indirect human action. Unsustainable anthropogenic land use in particular is one of the driving factors, besides global heating, for these ecologically critical developments. Precisely because land use is anthropogenic, it is also a factor that could be quickly and immediately corrected by human action.
In this thesis, I therefore assess the impact of three climate change scenarios of increasing intensity in combination with differently scheduled mowing regimes on the long-term development and dispersal success of insects in Northwest German grasslands. The large marsh grasshopper (LMG, Stethophyma grossum, Linné 1758) is used as a species of reference for the analyses. It inhabits wet meadows and marshes and has a limited, yet fairly good ability to disperse. Mowing and climate conditions affect the development and mortality of the LMG differently depending on its life stage.
The specifically developed simulation model HiLEG (High-resolution Large Environmental
Gradient) serves as a tool for investigating and projecting viability and dispersal success under different climate conditions and land use scenarios. It is a spatially explicit, stage- and cohort-based model that can be individually configured to represent the life cycle and characteristics of terrestrial insect species, as well as high-resolution environmental data and the occurrence of external disturbances. HiLEG is a freely available and adjustable software that can be used to support conservation planning in cultivated grasslands.
In the three case studies of this thesis, I explore various aspects related to the structure of simulation models per se, their importance in conservation planning in general, and insights regarding the LMG in particular. It became apparent that the detailed resolution of model processes and components is crucial to project the long-term effect of spatially and temporally confined events. Taking into account conservation measures at the regional level has further proven relevant, especially in light of the climate crisis. I found that the LMG is benefiting from global warming in principle, but continues to be constrained by harmful mowing regimes. Land use measures could, however, be adapted in such a way that they allow the expansion and establishment of the LMG without overly affecting agricultural yields.
Overall, simulation models like HiLEG can make an important contribution and add value
to conservation planning and policy-making. Properly used, simulation results shed light
on aspects that might be overlooked by subjective judgment and the experience of individual stakeholders. Even though it is in the nature of models that they are subject to limitations and only represent fragments of reality, this should not keep stakeholders from using them, as long as these limitations are clearly communicated. Similar to HiLEG, models could further be designed in such a way that not only the parameterization can be adjusted as required, but also the implementation itself can be improved and changed as desired. This openness and flexibility should become more widespread in the development of simulation models.
Inflammatory bowel diseases (IBD), characterised by a chronic inflammation of the gut wall, develop as consequence of an overreacting immune response to commensal bacteria, caused by a combination of genetic and environmental conditions. Large inter-individual differences in the outcome of currently available therapies complicate the decision for the best option for an individual patient. Predicting the prospects of therapeutic success for an individual patient is currently only possible to a limited extent; for this, a better understanding of possible differences between responders and non-responders is needed.
In this thesis, we have developed a mathematical model describing the most important processes of the gut mucosal immune system on the cellular level. The model is based on literature data, which were on the one hand used (qualitatively) to choose which cell types and processes to incorporate and to derive the model structure, and on the other hand (quantitatively) to derive the parameter values. Using ordinary differential equations, it describes the concentration-time course of neutrophils, macrophages, dendritic cells, T cells and bacteria, each subdivided into different cell types and activation states, in the lamina propria and mesenteric lymph nodes. We evaluate the model by means of simulations of the healthy immune response to salmonella infection and mucosal injury.
A virtual population includes IBD patients, which we define through their initially asymptomatic, but after a trigger chronically inflamed gut wall. We demonstrate the model's usefulness in different analyses: (i) The comparison of virtual IBD patients with virtual healthy individuals shows that the disease is elicited by many small or fewer large changes, and allows to make hypotheses about dispositions relevant for development of the disease. (ii) We simulate the effects of different therapeutic targets and make predictions about the therapeutic outcome based on the pre-treatment state. (iii) From the analysis of differences between virtual responders and non-responders, we derive hypotheses about reasons for the inter-individual variability in treatment outcome. (iv) For the example of anti-TNF-alpha therapy, we analyse, which alternative therapies are most promising in case of therapeutic failure, and which therapies are most suited for combination therapies: For drugs also directly targeting the cytokine levels or inhibiting the recruitment of innate immune cells, we predict a low probability of success when used as alternative treatment, but a large gain when used in a combination treatment. For drugs with direct effects on T cells, via modulation of the sphingosine-1-phosphate receptor or inhibition of T cell proliferation, we predict a considerably larger probability of success when used as alternative treatment, but only a small additional gain when used in a combination therapy.