Institut für Sportmedizin und Prävention
Refine
Year of publication
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (35) (remove)
Is part of the Bibliography
- yes (35)
Keywords
- Rumpf (2)
- Tendinopathie (2)
- Wirbelsäule (2)
- low back pain (2)
- spine (2)
- tendinopathy (2)
- trunk (2)
- 2-wyas translation (1)
- Achilles tendon (1)
- Achillessehne (1)
Institute
BACKGROUND: Physical activity involving high spinal load has been exposed to possess a crucial impact in the genesis of acute and chronic low back pain and disorder. Vigorous spinal loads are surmised in drop landings, for which strenuous bending loads were formerly evinced for the lower extremity structures. Thus far, clinical studies revealed that repetitive landing impacts can evoke benign structural adaptions or damage to the lumbar vertebrae. Though, causes for these observations are hitherto not conclusively evinced; since actual spinal load has to date not been experimentally documented. Moreover, it is yet undetermined how physiological activation of trunk musculature compensates for landing impact induced spinal loads, and to which extend trunk activity and spinal load are affected by landing demands and performer characteristics. AIMS of this study are 1. the localisation and quantification of spinal bending loads under various landing demands and 2. the identification of compensatory trunk muscular activity pattern, which potentially alleviate spinal load magnitudes. Three consecutive Hypotheses (H1 - H3) were hereto postulated: H1 posits that spinal bending loads in segregated motion planes can feasibly and reliably be evaluated from peak spine segmental angular accelerations. H2 furthermore assumes that vertical drop landings elicit highest spine bending load in sagittal flexion of the lumbar spine. Based on these verifications, a second study shall prove the successive hypothesis (H3) that diversified landing conditions, like performer’s landing familiarity and gender, as an implementation of an instantaneous follow-up task, affect the emerging lumbar spinal bending load. Herein it is moreover surmised that lumbar spinal bending loads under distinct landing conditions are predominantly modulated by herewith disparately deployed conditioned pre-activations of trunk muscles. METHODS: To test the above arrayed hypothesis, two successive studies were carried out. In STUDY 1, 17 subjects were repetitively assessed performing various drop landings (heigth: 15, 30, 45, 60cm; unilateral, bilateral, blindfolded, catching a ball) in a test-retest-design. Herein individual peak angular accelerations [αMAX] were derived from three-dimensional motion data of four trunk-segments (upper thoracic, lower thoracic, lumbar, pelvis). αMAX was herein assessed in flexion, lateral flexion, and rotation of each spinal joint, formed by two adjacent segments. Reliability of αMAX within and between test-days was evaluated by CV%, ICC 2.1, TRV%, and Bland & Altman Analysis (BIAS±LoA). Subsequently, peak flexion acceleration of the lumbo-pelvic joint [αFLEX[LS-PV]] was statistically compared to αMAX expressions of each other assessed spinal joint and motion plane (Mean ±SD, Independent Samples T-test). STUDY 2 deliberately assessed mere peak lumbo-pelvic flexion accelerations [αFLEX[LS-PV]] and electro-myographic trunk pre-activity prior to αFLEX[LS-PV] on 43 subjects performing varied landing tasks (height 45cm; with definite or indefinite predictability of a subsequent instant follow up jump). Subjects were contrasted with respect to their previous landing familiarity ( >1000 vs. <100 landings performed in the past 10 years) and gender. Differences of αFLEX[LS-PV] and muscular pre-activity between contrasted subject groups as between landing tasks were equally statistically tested by three-way mixed ANOVA with Post-hoc tests. Associations between αFLEX[LS-PV] and muscular pre-activity were factor-specifically assessed by Spearman’s rank order correlation coefficient (rS). Complementarily, muscular pre-activity was subdivided by landing phases [DROP, IMPACT] and discretely assessed for phase specific associations to αFLEX[LS-PV]. Each muscular activity was moreover pairwise compared between DROP and IMPACT (Mean ±SD, Dependent Samples T-test). RESULTS: αMAX was presented with overall high variability within test-days (CV =36%). Lowest intra-individual variability and highest reproducibility of αMAX between test-days was shown in flexion of the spine. αFLEX[LS-PV] showed largely consistent sig. higher magnitudes compared to αMAX presented in more cranial spinal joints and other motion planes. αFLEX[LS-PV] moreover gradually increased with escalations in landing heights. Landing unfamiliar subjects presented sig. higher αFLEX[LS-PV] in contrast to landing familiar ones (p=.016). M. Obliquus Int. with M. Transversus Abd. (66 ±32%MVC) and M. Erector Spinae (47 ±15%MVC) presented maredly highest activity in contrast to lowest activity of M. Rectus Abd. (10 ±4%MVC). Landing unfamiliar subjects showed compared to landing familiar ones sig. higher activity of M. Obliquus Ext. (17 ±8%MVC, 12 ±7%MVC, p= .044). M. Obliquus Ext. and its co-contraction ratio with M. Erector Spinae moreover exhibited low but sig. positive correlations to αFLEX[LS-PV] (rs=.39, rs=.31). Each trunk muscule distributed larger shares of its activity to DROP, whereas peak activations of most muscles emerged in the proportionally shorter IMPACT phase. Commonly increased muscular pre-activation particularly at IMPACT was found in landings with a contrived follow up jump and in female subjects, whereby αFLEX[LS-PV] was hereof only marginally affected. DISCUSSION: Highest spine segmental angular accelerations in drop landings emerge in sagittal flexion of the lumbar spine. The compensatory stabilisation of the spine appears to be preponderantly provided by a dorso-ventral co-contraction of M. Obliquus Int., M. Transversus Abd. and M. Erector Spinae. Elevated pre-activity of M. Obliquuis Ext. supposably characterises poor landing experience, which might engender increased bending loads to the lumbar spine. A pervasive large variability of spinal angular accelerations measured across all landing types, suggests a multifarious utilisation of diverse mechanisms compensating for spinal impacts in landing performances. A standardised assessment and valid evaluation of landing evoked lumbar bending loads is hereof largley confined. CONCLUSION: Drop landings elicit most strenuous lumbo-pelvic flexion accelerations, which can be appraised as representatives for high energetic bending loads to the spine. Such entail the highest risk to overload the spinal tissue, when landing demands exceed the individual’s landing skill. Previous landing experience and training appears to effectively improve muscular spine stabilisation pattern, diminishing spinal bending loads.
Introduction: Carbohydrate (CHO) and fat are the main substrates to fuel prolonged endurance exercise, each having its oxidation patterns regulated by several factors such as intensity, duration and mode of the activity, dietary intake pattern, muscle glycogen concentrations, gender and training status. Exercising at intensities where fat oxidation rates are high has been shown to induce metabolic benefits in recreational and health-oriented sportsmen. The exercise intensity (Fatpeak) eliciting peak fat oxidation rates is therefore of particular interest when aiming to prescribe exercise for the purpose of fat oxidation and related metabolic effects. Although running and walking are feasible and popular among the target population, no reliable protocols are available to assess Fatpeak as well as its actual velocity (VPFO) during treadmill ergometry. Moreover, to date, it remains unclear how pre-exercise CHO availability modulates the oxidative regulation of substrates when exercise is conducted at the intensity where the individual anaerobic threshold (IAT) is located (VIAT). That is, a metabolic marker representing the upper border where constant load endurance exercise can be sustained, being commonly used to guide athletic training or in performance diagnostics. The research objectives of the current thesis were therefore, 1) to assess the reliability and day-to-day variability of VPFO and Fatpeak during treadmill ergometry running; 2) to assess the impact of high CHO (HC) vs. low CHO (LC) diets (where on the LC day a combination of low CHO diet and a glycogen depleting exercise was implemented) on the oxidative regulation of CHOs and fat while exercise is conducted at VIAT. Methods: Research objective 1: Sixteen recreational athletes (f=7, m=9; 25 ± 3 y; 1.76 ± 0.09 m; 68.3 ± 13.7 kg; 23.1 ± 2.9 kg/m²) performed 2 different running protocols on 3 different days with standardized nutrition the day before testing. At day 1, peak oxygen uptake (VO2peak) and the velocities at the aerobic threshold (VLT) and respiratory exchange ratio (RER) of 1.00 (VRER) were assessed. At days 2 and 3, subjects ran an identical submaximal incremental test (Fat-peak test) composed of a 10 min warm-up (70% VLT) followed by 5 stages of 6 min with equal increments (stage 1 = VLT, stage 5 = VRER). Breath-by-breath gas exchange data was measured continuously and used to determine fat oxidation rates. A third order polynomial function was used to identify VPFO and subsequently Fatpeak. The reproducibility and variability of variables was verified with an intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), Pearson’s correlation coefficient, coefficient of variation (CV) and the mean differences (bias) ± 95% limits of agreement (LoA). Research objective 2: Sixteen recreational runners (m=8, f=8; 28 ± 3 y; 1.76 ± 0.09 m; 72 ± 13 kg; 23 ± 2 kg/m²) performed 3 different running protocols, each allocated on a different day. At day 1, a maximal stepwise incremental test was implemented to assess the IAT and VIAT. During days 2 and 3, participants ran a constant-pace bout (30 min) at VIAT that was combined with randomly assigned HC (7g/kg/d) or LC (3g/kg/d) diets for the 24 h before testing. Breath-by-breath gas exchange data was measured continuously and used to determine substrate oxidation. Dietary data and differences in substrate oxidation were analyzed with a paired t-test. A two-way ANOVA tested the diet X gender interaction (α = 0.05). Results: Research objective 1: ICC, Pearson’s correlation and CV for VPFO and Fatpeak were 0.98, 0.97, 5.0%; and 0.90, 0.81, 7.0%, respectively. Bias ± 95% LoA was -0.3 ± 0.9 km/h for VPFO and -2 ± 8% of VO2peak for Fatpeak. Research objective 2: Overall, the IAT and VIAT were 2.74 ± 0.39 mmol/l and 11.1 ± 1.4 km/h, respectively. CHO oxidation was 3.45 ± 0.08 and 2.90 ± 0.07 g/min during HC and LC bouts respectively (P < 0.05). Likewise, fat oxidation was 0.13 ± 0.03 and 0.36 ± 0.03 g/min (P < 0.05). Females had 14% (P < 0.05) and 12% (P > 0.05) greater fat oxidation compared to males during HC and LC bouts, respectively. Conclusions: Research objective 1: In summary, relative and absolute reliability indicators for VPFO and Fatpeak were found to be excellent. The observed LoA may now serve as a basis for future training prescriptions, although fat oxidation rates at prolonged exercise bouts at this intensity still need to be investigated. Research objective 2: Twenty-four hours of high CHO consumption results in concurrent higher CHO oxidation rates and overall utilization, whereas maintaining a low systemic CHO availability significantly increases the contribution of fat to the overall energy metabolism. The observed gender differences underline the necessity of individualized dietary planning before exerting at intensities associated with performance exercise. Ultimately, future research should establish how these findings can be extrapolated to training and competitive situations and with that provide trainers and nutritionists with improved data to derive training prescriptions.
Professionelle GT Langstreckenmotorsportler (Rennfahrer) müssen den hohen motorischen und kognitiven Ansprüchen ohne Verlust der Performance während eines Rennens endgegenwirken können. Sie müssen stets, bei hoher Geschwindigkeit fokussiert und konzentriert auf ihr Auto, die Rennstrecke und ihre Gegner reagieren können. Darüber hinaus sind Rennfahrer zusätzlich durch die notwendige Kommunikation im Auto mit den Ingenieuren und Mechanikern in der Boxengasse gefordert. Daten über die tatsächliche Beanspruchung und häufig auftretende Beschwerden und/oder Verletzung von Profiathleten liegen kaum vor. Für eine möglichst gute Performance im Auto während eines Rennens ist es notwendige neben der körperlichen Beanspruchung auch die häufigen Krankheitsbilder zu kennen. Auf Basis dessen kann eine optimale Prävention oder notwendige Therapie zur möglichst schnellen Reintegration in den Sport abgeleitet und entwickelt werden. Die vorliegende Arbeit befasst sich durch ein regelmäßiges Gesundheitsmonitoring mit der Erfassung häufiger Beschwerden und oder Verletzungen im GT Langestreckenmotorsport zur Ableitung eines präventiven (trainingstherapeutischen) und therapeutischen Konzeptes. Darüber hinaus, soll über die Einschätzung der körperlichen Leistungsfähigkeit der Athleten, auf Basis der Beanspruchung im Rennfahrzeug ein mögliches Trainingskonzept in Abhängigkeit der Saison entwickelt werden.
Insgesamt wurden über 15 Jahre (2003-2017) 37 männliche Athleten aus dem GT Langstreckenmotorsport 353mal im Rahmen eines Gesundheitsmonitorings untersucht. Dabei wurden Athleten maximal 14 Jahre und mindestens 1 Jahr sportmedizinische betreut. Diese 2x im Jahr stattfindende Untersuchung beinhaltete im Wesentlichen eine sportmedizinische Untersuchung zur Einschätzung der Tauglichkeit für den Sport und die Erfassung der körperlichen Leistungsfähigkeit. Über das Gesundheitsmonitoring hinaus erfolgte die Betreuung zusätzlich an der Rennstrecke zur weiteren Erfassung der Beschwerden, Erkrankungen und Verletzungen der Athleten während ihrer sportartspezifischen Belastung. Zusammengefasst zeigen die Athleten geringe Prävalenzen und Inzidenzen der Krankheitsbilder bzw. Beschwerden. Ein Unterschied der Prävalenzen zeigt sich zwischen den Gesundheitsuntersuchungen und der Betreuung an der Rennstrecke. Die häufigsten Beschwerdebilder zeigen sich aus Orthopädie und Innerer Medizin. So sind Infekte der oberen Atemwege sowie Allergien neben Beschwerden der unteren Extremität und der Wirbelsäule am häufigsten. Demzufolge werden vorrangig physio- und trainingstherapeutische Konsequenzen abgeleitet. Eine medikamentöse Therapie erfolgt im Wesentlichen während der Rennbetreuung. Zur Reduktion der orthopädischen und internistischen Beschwerden sollten präventive Maßnahmen mehr betont werden. Die körperliche Leistungsfähigkeit zeigt im Wesentlichen über die Untersuchungsjahre eine stabile Performance für die Ausdauer-, Kraft und sensomotorische Leistungsfähigkeit. Die Ausdauerleistungsfähigkeit kann in Abhängigkeit der Sportartspezifik mit einer guten bis sehr guten Ausprägung definiert werden. Die Kraftleistungsfähigkeit und die sensomotorische Leistungsfähigkeit lassen sportartspezifische Unterschiede zu und sollte körpergewichtsbezogen betrachtet werden.
Ein sportmedizinisches und trainingstherapeutisches Konzept müsste demnach eine regelmäßige ärztlich-medizinische Untersuchung mit dem Fokus der Orthopädie, Inneren Medizin und Hals- Nasen-Ohren-Kunde beinhalten. Darüber hinaus sollte eine regelmäßige Erfassung der körperlichen Leistungsfähigkeit zur möglichst effektiven Ableitung von Trainingsinhalten oder Präventionsmaßnahmen berücksichtig werden. Auf Grundlage der hohen Reisetätigkeit und der ganzjährigen Saison könnte ein 1-2x jährlich stattfindendes Trainingslager, im Sinne eines Grundlagen- und Aufbautrainings zur Optimierung der Leistungsfähigkeit beitragen, das Konzept komplementieren. Zudem scheint eine ärztliche Rennbetreuung notwendig.
Hintergrund
Für Patienten mit hochgradiger Aortenklappenstenose, die aufgrund ihres Alters oder ihrer Multimorbidität ein hohes Operationsrisiko tragen, konnte mit der kathetergestützten Aortenklappenkorrektur (transcatheter aortic valve implantation, TAVI) eine vielversprechende Alternative zum herzchirurgischen Eingriff etabliert werden. Explizite Daten zur multidisziplinären kardiologischen Rehabilitation nach TAVI liegen bislang nicht vor. Ziel vorliegender Arbeit war, den Effekt der kardiologischen Rehabilitation auf die körperliche Leistungsfähigkeit, den emotionalen Status, die Lebensqualität und die Gebrechlichkeit bei Patienten nach TAVI zu untersuchen sowie Prädiktoren für die Veränderung der körperlichen Leistungsfähigkeit und der Lebensqualität zu identifizieren.
Methodik
Zwischen 10/2013 und 07/2015 wurden 136 Patienten (80,6 ± 5,0 Jahre, 47,8 % Männer) in Anschlussheilbehandlung nach TAVI in drei kardiologischen Rehabilitationskliniken eingeschlossen. Zur Beurteilung des Effekts der kardiologischen Rehabilitation wurden jeweils zu Beginn und Ende der Rehabilitation der Frailty (Gebrechlichkeits)-Index (Score bestehend aus Barthel-Index, Instrumental Activities of Daily Living, Mini Mental State Exam, Mini Nutritional Assessment, Timed Up and Go und subjektiver Mobilitätsverschlechterung), die Lebensqualität im Short-Form 12 (SF-12) sowie die funktionale körperliche Leistungsfähigkeit im 6-Minuten Gehtest (6-minute walk test, 6MWT) und die maximale körperliche Leistungsfähigkeit in der Belastungs-Ergometrie erhoben. Zusätzlich wurden soziodemographische Daten (z. B. Alter und Geschlecht), Komorbiditäten (z. B. chronisch obstruktive Lungenerkrankung, koronare Herzkrankheit und Karzinom), kardiovaskuläre Risikofaktoren und die NYHA-Klasse dokumentiert. Prädiktoren für die Veränderung der körperlichen Leistungsfähigkeit und Lebensqualität wurden mit Kovarianzanalysen angepasst.
Ergebnisse
Die maximale Gehstrecke im 6MWT konnte um 56,3 ± 65,3 m (p < 0,001) und die maximale körperliche Leistungsfähigkeit in der Belastungs-Ergometrie um 8,0 ± 14,9 Watt (p < 0001) gesteigert werden. Weiterhin konnte eine Verbesserung im SF-12 sowohl in der körperlichen Summenskala um 2,5 ± 8,7 Punkte (p = 0,001) als auch in der psychischen Summenskala um 3,4 ± 10,2 Punkte (p = 0,003) erreicht werden. In der multivariaten Analyse waren ein höheres Alter und eine höhere Bildung signifikant mit einer geringeren Zunahme im 6MWT assoziiert, währenddessen eine bessere kognitive Leistungsfähigkeit und Adipositas einen positiven prädiktiven Wert aufwiesen. Eine höhere Selbstständigkeit und ein besserer Ernährungsstatus beeinflussten die Veränderung in der körperlichen Summenskala des SF-12 positiv, währenddessen eine bessere kognitive Leistungsfähigkeit einen Prädiktor für eine geringere Veränderung darstellte. Des Weiteren hatten die jeweiligen Ausgangswerte der körperlichen und psychischen Summenskala im SF-12 einen inversen Einfluss auf die Veränderungen in der gleichen Skala.
Schlussfolgerung
Eine multidisziplinäre kardiologische Rehabilitation kann sowohl die körperliche Leistungs-fähigkeit und Lebensqualität verbessern als auch die Gebrechlichkeit von Patienten nach kathetergestützter Aortenklappenkorrektur verringern. Daraus resultierend gilt es, spezifische Assessments für die kardiologische Rehabilitation zu entwickeln. Weiterhin ist es notwendig, individualisierte Therapieprogramme mit besonderem Augenmerk auf kognitive Funktionen und Ernährung zu initiieren, um die Selbstständigkeit hochbetagter Patienten zu erhalten bzw. wiederherzustellen und um die Pflegebedürftigkeit der Patienten hinauszuzögern.
Background: Low back pain (LBP) is one of the world wide leading causes of limited activity and disability. Impaired motor control has been found to be one of the possible factors related to the development or persistence of LBP. In particularly, motor control strategies seemed to be altered in situations requiring reactive responses of the trunk counteracting sudden external forces. However, muscular responses were mostly assessed in (quasi) static testing situations under simplified laboratory conditions. Comprehensive investigations in motor control strategies during dynamic everyday situations are lacking. The present research project aimed to investigate muscular compensation strategies following unexpected gait perturbations in people with and without LBP. A novel treadmill stumbling protocol was tested for its validity and reliability to provoke muscular reflex responses at the trunk and the lower extremities (study 1). Thereafter, motor control strategies in response to sudden perturbations were compared between people with LBP and asymptomatic controls (CTRL) (study 2). In accordance with more recent concepts of motor adaptation to pain, it was hypothesized that pain may have profound consequences on motor control strategies in LBP. Therefore, it was investigated whether differences in compensation strategies were either consisting of changes local to the painful area at the trunk, or also being present in remote areas such as at the lower extremities.
Methods: All investigations were performed on a custom build split-belt treadmill simulating trip-like events by unexpected rapid deceleration impulses (amplitude: 2 m/s; duration: 100 ms; 200 ms after heel contact) at 1m/s baseline velocity. A total number of 5 (study 1) and 15 (study 2) right sided perturbations were applied during walking trials. Muscular activities were assessed by surface electromyography (EMG), recorded at 12 trunk muscles and 10 (study 1) respectively 5 (study 2) leg muscles. EMG latencies of muscle onset [ms] were retrieved by a semi-automatic detection method. EMG amplitudes (root mean square (RMS)) were assessed within 200 ms post perturbation, normalized to full strides prior to any perturbation [RMS%]. Latency and amplitude investigations were performed for each muscle individually, as well as for pooled data of muscles grouped by location. Characteristic pain intensity scores (CPIS; 0-100 points, von Korff) based on mean intensity ratings reported for current, worst and average pain over the last three months were used to allocate participants into LBP (≥30 points) or CTRL (≤10 points). Test-retest reproducibility between measurements was determined by a compilation of measures of reliability. Differences in muscular activities between LBP and CTRL were analysed descriptively for individual muscles; differences based on grouped muscles were statistically tested by using a multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA, α =0.05).
Results: Thirteen individuals were included into the analysis of study 1. EMG latencies revealed reflex muscle activities following the perturbation (mean: 89 ms). Respective EMG amplitudes were on average 5-fold of those assessed in unperturbed strides, though being characterized by a high inter-subject variability. Test-retest reliability of muscle latencies showed a high reproducibility, both for muscles at the trunk and legs. In contrast, reproducibility of amplitudes was only weak to moderate for individual muscles, but increased when being assessed as a location specific outcome summary of grouped muscles. Seventy-six individuals were eligible for data analysis in study 2. Group allocation according to CPIS resulted in n=25 for LBP and n=29 for CTRL. Descriptive analysis of activity onsets revealed longer delays for all muscles within LBP compared to CTRL (trunk muscles: mean 10 ms; leg muscles: mean 3 ms). Onset latencies of grouped muscles revealed statistically significant differences between LBP and CTRL for right (p=0.009) and left (p=0.007) abdominal muscle groups. EMG amplitude analysis showed a high variability in activation levels between individuals, independent of group assignment or location. Statistical testing of grouped muscles indicated no significant difference in amplitudes between LBP and CTRL.
Discussion: The present research project could show that perturbed treadmill walking is suitable to provoke comprehensive reflex responses at the trunk and lower extremities, both in terms of sudden onsets and amplitudes of reflex activity. Moreover, it could demonstrate that sudden loadings under dynamic conditions provoke an altered reflex timing of muscles surrounding the trunk in people with LBP compared to CTRL. In line with previous investigations, compensation strategies seemed to be deployed in a task specific manner, with differences between LBP and CTRL being evident predominately at ventral sides. No muscular alterations exceeding the trunk could be found when being assessed under the automated task of locomotion. While rehabilitation programs tailored towards LBP are still under debate, it is tempting to urge the implementation of dynamic sudden loading incidents of the trunk to enhance motor control and thereby to improve spinal protection. Moreover, in respect to the consistently observed task specificity of muscular compensation strategies, such a rehabilitation program should be rich in variety.
Prevalence of Achilles tendinopathy increases with age, leading to a weaker tendon with predisposition to rupture. Previous studies, investigating Achilles tendon (AT) properties, are restricted to standardized isometric conditions. Knowledge regarding the influence of age and pa-thology on AT response under functional tasks remains limited. Therefore, the aim of the thesis was to investigate the influence of age and pathology on AT properties during a single-leg vertical jump.
Healthy children, asymptomatic adults and patients with Achilles tendinopathy participated. Ultrasonography was used to assess AT-length, AT-cross-sectional area and AT-elongation. The reliability of the methodology used was evaluated both Intra- and inter-rater at rest and at maximal isometric plantar-flexion contraction and was further implemented to investigate tendon properties during functional task. During the functional task a single-leg vertical jump on a force plate was performed while simultaneously AT elongation and vertical ground reaction forces were recorded. AT compliance [mm/N] (elongation/force) and AT strain [%] (elongation/length) were calculated. Differences between groups were evaluated with respect to age (children vs. adults) and pathology (asymptomatic adults vs. patients).
Good to excellent reliability with low levels of variability was achieved in the assessment of AT properties. During the jumps AT elongation was found to be statistical significant higher in children. However, no statistical significant difference was found for force among the groups. AT compliance and strain were found to be statistical significant higher only in children. No significant differences were found between asymptomatic adults and patients with tendinopathy.
The methodology used to assess AT properties is reliable, allowing its implementation into further investigations. Higher AT-compliance in children might be considered as a protective factor against load-related injuries. During functional task, when higher forces are acting on the AT, tendinopathy does not result in a weaker tendon.
A majority of studies documented a reduced ankle muscle activity, particularly of the peroneus longus muscle (PL), in patients with functional ankle instability (FI). It is considered valid that foot orthoses as well as sensorimotor training have a positive effect on ankle muscle activity in healthy individuals and those with lower limb overuse injuries or flat arched feet (reduced reaction time by sensorimotor exercises; increased ankle muscle amplitude by orthoses use). However, the acute- and long-term influence of foot orthoses on ankle muscle activity in individuals with FI is unknown.
AIMS: The present thesis addressed (1a) acute- and (1b) long-term effects of foot orthoses compared to sensorimotor training on ankle muscle activity in patients with FI. (2) Further, it was investigated if the orthosis intervention group demonstrate higher ankle muscle activity by additional short-term use of a measurement in-shoe orthosis (compared to short-term use of “shoe only”) after intervention. (3) As prerequisite, it was evaluated if ankle muscle activity can be tested reliably and (4) if this differs between healthy individuals and those with FI.
METHODS: Three intervention groups (orthosis group [OG], sensorimotor training group [SMTG], control group [CG]), consisting of both, healthy individuals and those with FI, underwent one longitudinal investigation (randomised controlled trial). Throughout 6 weeks of intervention, OG wore an in-shoe orthosis with a specific “PL stimulation module”, whereas SMTG conducted home-based exercises. CG served to measure test-retest reliability of ankle muscle activity (PL, M. tibialis anterior [TA] and M. gastrocnemius medialis [GM]). Pre- and post-intervention, ankle muscle activity (EMG amplitude) was recorded during “normal” unperturbed (NW) and perturbed walking (PW) on a split-belt treadmill (stimulus 200 ms post initial heel contact [IC]) as well as during side cutting (SC), each while wearing “shoes only” and additional measurement in-shoe orthoses (randomized order). Normalized RMS values (100% MVC, mean±SD) were calculated pre- (100-50 ms) and post (200-400 ms) - IC.
RESULTS: (3) Test-retest reliability showed a high range of values in healthy individuals and those with FI. (4) Compared to healthy individuals, patients with FI demonstrated lower PL pre-activity during SC, however higher PL pre-activity for NW and PW. (1a) Acute orthoses use did not influence ankle muscle activity. (1b) For most conditions, sensorimotor training was more effective in individuals with FI than long-term orthotic intervention (increased: PL and GM pre-activity and TA reflex-activity for NW, PL pre-activity and TA, PL and GM reflex-activity for SC, PL reflex-activity for PW). However, prolonged orthoses use was more beneficial in terms of an increase in GM pre-activity during SC. For some conditions, long-term orthoses intervention was as effective as sensorimotor training for individuals with FI (increased: PL pre-activity for PW, TA pre-activity for SC, PL and GM reflex-activity for NW). Prolonged orthoses use was also advantageous in healthy individuals (increased: PL and GM pre-activity for NW and PW, PL pre-activity for SC, TA and PL reflex-activity for NW, PL and GM reflex-activity for PW). (2) The orthosis intervention group did not present higher ankle muscle activity by the additional short-term use of a measurement in-shoe orthosis at re-test after intervention.
CONCLUSION: High variations of reproducibility reflect physiological variability in muscle activity during gait and therefore deemed acceptable. The main findings confirm the presence of sensorimotor long-term effects of specific foot orthoses in healthy individuals (primary preventive effect) and those with FI (therapeutic effect). Neuromuscular compensatory feedback- as well as anticipatory feedforward adaptation mechanism to prolonged orthoses use, specifically of the PL muscle, underpins the key role of PL in providing essential dynamic ankle joint stability. Due to its advantages over sensorimotor training (positive subjective feedback in terms of comfort, time-and-cost-effectiveness), long-term foot orthoses use can be recommended as an applicable therapy alternative in the treatment of FI. Long-term effect of foot orthoses in a population with FI must be validated in a larger sample size with longer follow-up periods to substantiate the generalizability of the existing outcomes.