TY - JOUR A1 - Niemz, Peter A1 - Dahm, Torsten A1 - Milkereit, Claus A1 - Cesca, Simone A1 - Petersen, Gesa Maria A1 - Zang, Arno T1 - Insights into hydraulic fracture growth gained from a joint analysis of seismometer-derived tilt signals and scoustic emissions JF - Journal of geophysical research : Solid earth N2 - Hydraulic fracturing is performed to enhance rock permeability, for example, in the frame of geothermal energy production or shale gas exploitation, and can potentially trigger induced seismicity. The tracking of increased permeabilities and the fracturing extent is often based on the microseismic event distribution within the stimulated rock volume, but it is debated whether the microseismic activity adequately depicts the fracture formation. We are able to record tilt signals that appear as long-period transients (<180 s) on two broadband seismometers installed close (17-72 m) to newly formed, meter-scale hydraulic fractures. With this observation, we can overcome the limitations of the microseismic monitoring alone and verify the fracture mapping. Our analysis for the first time combines a catalog of previously analyzed acoustic emissions ([AEs] durations of 20 ms), indirectly mapping the fractures, with unique tilt signals, that provide independent, direct insights into the deformation of the rock. The analysis allows to identify different phases of the fracturing process including the (re)opening, growth, and aftergrowth of fractures. Further, it helps to differentiate between the formation of complex fracture networks and single macrofractures, and it validates the AE fracture mapping. Our findings contribute to a better understanding of the fracturing processes, which may help to reduce fluid-injection-induced seismicity and validate efficient fracture formation.
Plain Language Summary Hydraulic fracturing (HF) describes the opening of fractures in rocks by injecting fluids under high pressure. The new fractures not only can facilitate the extraction of shale gas but can also be used to heat up water in the subsurface in enhanced geothermal systems, a corner stone of renewable energy production. The fracture formation is inherently accompanied by small, nonfelt earthquakes (microseismic events). Occasionally, larger events felt by the population can be induced by the subsurface operations. Avoiding such events is important for the acceptance of HF operations and requires a detailed knowledge about the fracture formation. We jointly analyze two very different data sets recorded during mine-scale HF experiments: (a) the tilting of the ground caused by the opening of the fractures, as recorded by broadband seismometers-usually deployed for earthquake monitoring-installed close to the experiments and (b) a catalog of acoustic emissions, seismic signals of few milliseconds emitted by tiny cracks around the forming hydraulic fracture. The novel joint analysis allows to characterize the fracturing processes in greater detail, contributing to the understanding of the physical processes, which may help to understand fluid-injection-induced seismicity and validate the formation of hydraulic fractures. KW - hydraulic fracturing KW - fracture growth KW - tilt KW - acoustic emissions KW - injections KW - broadband seismometer Y1 - 2021 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1029/2021JB023057 SN - 2169-9313 SN - 2169-9356 VL - 126 IS - 12 PB - American Geophysical Union CY - Washington ER - TY - JOUR A1 - López-Comino, José Ángel A1 - Cesca, Simone A1 - Niemz, Peter A1 - Dahm, Torsten A1 - Zang, Arno T1 - Rupture directivity in 3D inferred from acoustic emissions events in a mine-scale hydraulic fracturing experiment JF - Frontiers in Earth Science N2 - Rupture directivity, implying a predominant earthquake rupture propagation direction, is typically inferred upon the identification of 2D azimuthal patterns of seismic observations for weak to large earthquakes using surface-monitoring networks. However, the recent increase of 3D monitoring networks deployed in the shallow subsurface and underground laboratories toward the monitoring of microseismicity allows to extend the directivity analysis to 3D modeling, beyond the usual range of magnitudes. The high-quality full waveforms recorded for the largest, decimeter-scale acoustic emission (AE) events during a meter-scale hydraulic fracturing experiment in granites at similar to 410 m depth allow us to resolve the apparent durations observed at each AE sensor to analyze 3D-directivity effects. Unilateral and (asymmetric) bilateral ruptures are then characterized by the introduction of a parameter kappa, representing the angle between the directivity vector and the station vector. While the cloud of AE activity indicates the planes of the hydrofractures, the resolved directivity vectors show off-plane orientations, indicating that rupture planes of microfractures on a scale of centimeters have different geometries. Our results reveal a general alignment of the rupture directivity with the orientation of the minimum horizontal stress, implying that not only the slip direction but also the fracture growth produced by the fluid injections is controlled by the local stress conditions. KW - directivity KW - earthquake source KW - induced seismicity KW - hydraulic KW - fracturing KW - acoustic emissions Y1 - 2021 U6 - https://doi.org/10.3389/feart.2021.670757 SN - 2296-6463 VL - 9 PB - Frontiers Media CY - Lausanne ER - TY - THES A1 - Niemz, Peter T1 - Imaging and modeling of hydraulic fractures in crystalline rock via induced seismic activity T1 - Charakterisierung und Modellierung hydraulischer Brüche in Kristallingestein mit Hilfe induzierter Seismizität N2 - Enhanced geothermal systems (EGS) are considered a cornerstone of future sustainable energy production. In such systems, high-pressure fluid injections break the rock to provide pathways for water to circulate in and heat up. This approach inherently induces small seismic events that, in rare cases, are felt or can even cause damage. Controlling and reducing the seismic impact of EGS is crucial for a broader public acceptance. To evaluate the applicability of hydraulic fracturing (HF) in EGS and to improve the understanding of fracturing processes and the hydromechanical relation to induced seismicity, six in-situ, meter-scale HF experiments with different injection schemes were performed under controlled conditions in crystalline rock in a depth of 410 m at the Äspö Hard Rock Laboratory (Sweden). I developed a semi-automated, full-waveform-based detection, classification, and location workflow to extract and characterize the acoustic emission (AE) activity from the continuous recordings of 11 piezoelectric AE sensors. Based on the resulting catalog of 20,000 AEs, with rupture sizes of cm to dm, I mapped and characterized the fracture growth in great detail. The injection using a novel cyclic injection scheme (HF3) had a lower seismic impact than the conventional injections. HF3 induced fewer AEs with a reduced maximum magnitude and significantly larger b-values, implying a decreased number of large events relative to the number of small ones. Furthermore, HF3 showed an increased fracture complexity with multiple fractures or a fracture network. In contrast, the conventional injections developed single, planar fracture zones (Publication 1). An independent, complementary approach based on a comparison of modeled and observed tilt exploits transient long-period signals recorded at the horizontal components of two broad-band seismometers a few tens of meters apart from the injections. It validated the efficient creation of hydraulic fractures and verified the AE-based fracture geometries. The innovative joint analysis of AEs and tilt signals revealed different phases of the fracturing process, including the (re-)opening, growth, and aftergrowth of fractures, and provided evidence for the reactivation of a preexisting fault in one of the experiments (Publication 2). A newly developed network-based waveform-similarity analysis applied to the massive AE activity supports the latter finding. To validate whether the reduction of the seismic impact as observed for the cyclic injection schemes during the Äspö mine-scale experiments is transferable to other scales, I additionally calculated energy budgets for injection experiments from previously conducted laboratory tests and from a field application. Across all three scales, the cyclic injections reduce the seismic impact, as depicted by smaller maximum magnitudes, larger b-values, and decreased injection efficiencies (Publication 3). N2 - Hydraulisch-stimulierte tiefengeothermale Systeme (Enhanced Geothermal systems, EGS) gelten als einer der Eckpfeiler für die nachhaltige Energieerzeugung der Zukunft. In diesen geothermalen Systemen wird heißes Tiefengestein durch Fluidinjektionen unter hohem Druck aufgebrochen, um Wegsamkeiten zur Erwärmung von Wasser oder anderen Fluiden zu schaffen. Beim Aufbrechen werden zwangsläufig kleine seismische Ereignisse ausgelöst (induzierte Seismizität), die in sehr seltenen Fällen an der Oberfläche spürbar sind, jedoch in extremen Fällen auch Schäden verursachen können. Die Kontrolle bzw. die Reduzierung der seismischen Aktivität in EGS ist daher ein entscheidender Punkt, damit diese Art der Energiegewinnung eine breite gesellschaftliche Akzeptanz findet. Grundlage dieser Dissertation ist eine Serie von kontrollierten, hydraulischen Bruchexperimenten mit Bruchdimensionen von einigen Metern. Die Experimente wurden in einer Tiefe von 410 m in kristallinem Gestein eines Versuchsbergwerks (Äspö Hard Rock Laboratory, Schweden) mit unterschiedlichen Injektionsstrategien durchgeführt. Die detaillierte Auswertung der Bruch-Experimente in dieser Dissertation zielt darauf ab, die Nutzbarkeit von hydraulischen Stimulationen (hydraulic fracturing, HF) in EGS zu untersuchen und das Verständnis von Bruchprozessen sowie der hydromechanischen Beziehung zur induzierten Seismizität zu verbessern. Um die Schallemissionsaktivität (acoustic emissions, AE), die durch 11 piezoelektrische AE-Sensoren kontinuierlich aufgezeichnet wurde, zu extrahieren und zu charakterisieren, wurde ein halbautomatischer, wellenformbasierter Detektions-, Klassifizierungs- und Lokalisierungsworkflow entwickelt. Mit Hilfe des resultierenden Katalogs von 20000 AEs wurde das Bruchwachstum detailliert kartiert und charakterisiert. Das Experiment mit der neuartigen, zyklischen Injektionsstrategie (HF3) weist einen geringeren seismischen Fußabdruck auf als die Standard-Injektionsstrategie. HF3 induzierte weniger AEs und eine kleinere Maximalmagnitude. Außerdem hatte das Experiment einen signifikant höheren b-Wert, was einer verringerten Anzahl von großen AEs relativ zur Anzahl der kleineren AEs entspricht. Darüber hinaus zeigte HF3 eine erhöhte Komplexität im Bruchmuster mit mehreren Brüchen bzw. einem Netzwerk von Brüchen. Im Gegensatz dazu entwickelten die Standard-Injektionen einzelne, ebene Bruchzonen (Publikation 1). Zusätzlich zu den induzierten AEs wurden transiente, langperiodische Signale auf den horizontalen Komponenten von zwei Breitband-Seismometern, die wenige Meter von den Brüchen installiert waren, ausgewertet. Diese Signale wurden als Neigungssignale interpretiert und mit modellierten Neigungssignalen verglichen. Der Vergleich zeigt unabhängig, dass hydraulische Brüche geöffnet wurden und bestätigt, dass die AE-basierte Analyse die Bruchgeometrie verlässlich kartieren kann. Die gemeinsame Betrachtung von AEs und Neigungssignalen offenbart verschiedene Phasen des Bruchprozesses: das (wiederholte) Öffnen des Bruches, das Bruchwachstum und das weitere Wachsen des Bruches nach dem Ende der Injektion. Außerdem liefert die Analyse Hinweise auf die Reaktivierung einer natürlichen Bruchzone in einem der Experimente (Publikation 2). Eine neuentwickelte und hier präsentierte Wellenform-Ähnlichkeitsanalyse, die Informationen des gesamten Sensornetzwerkes nutzt und zum ersten Mal auf einen umfangreichen AE-Katalog angewendet wurde, unterstützt diese Interpretation. Um zu validieren, ob die verringerte Seismizität während der zyklischen Injektion auf der Meter-Skala (Bergwerk) auf andere Maßstäbe übertragbar ist, wurden Energie-Budgets für Injektionsexperimente aus zuvor durchgeführten Laborversuchen und aus einem Tiefengeothermie-Projekt berechnet. Über alle drei Skalen hinweg zeigen die zyklischen Injektionen einen verringerten seismischen Fußabdruck mit kleineren Maximalmagnituden, größeren b-Werte und einem kleineren Verhältnis von seismisch-abgestrahlter zu injizierter Energie (Publikation 3). KW - induced seismicity KW - hydraulic fracturing KW - enhanced geothermal systems (EGS) KW - injection KW - deformation KW - acoustic emissions KW - fracture growth KW - injection scheme KW - basement rock KW - Schallemissionen KW - Grundgestein KW - Deformation KW - verbesserte geothermische Systeme KW - Bruchausbreitung KW - hydraulisches Aufbrechen KW - Induzierte Seismizität KW - Injektion KW - Injektionsschema Y1 - 2022 U6 - http://nbn-resolving.de/urn/resolver.pl?urn:nbn:de:kobv:517-opus4-556593 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Niemz, Peter A1 - Cesca, Simone A1 - Heimann, Sebastian A1 - Grigoli, Francesco A1 - von Specht, Sebastian A1 - Hammer, Conny A1 - Zang, Arno A1 - Dahm, Torsten T1 - Full-waveform-based characterization of acoustic emission activity in a mine-scale experiment BT - a comparison of conventional and advanced hydraulic fracturing schemes JF - Geophysical journal international / the Royal Astronomical Society, the Deutsche Geophysikalische Gesellschaft and the European Geophysical Society N2 - Understanding fracturing processes and the hydromechanical relation to induced seismicity is a key question for enhanced geothermal systems (EGS). Commonly massive fluid injection, predominately causing hydroshearing, are used in large-scale EGS but also hydraulic fracturing approaches were discussed. To evaluate the applicability of hydraulic fracturing techniques in EGS, six in situ, multistage hydraulic fracturing experiments with three different injection schemes were performed under controlled conditions in crystalline rock at the Aspo Hard Rock Laboratory (Sweden). During the experiments the near-field ground motion was continuously recorded by 11 piezoelectric borehole sensors with a sampling rate of 1 MHz. The sensor network covered a volume of 30x30x30 m around a horizontal, 28-m-long injection borehole at a depth of 410 m. To extract and characterize massive, induced, high-frequency acoustic emission (AE) activity from continuous recordings, a semi-automated workflow was developed relying on full waveform based detection, classification and location procedures. The approach extended the AE catalogue from 196 triggered events in previous studies to more than 19600 located AEs. The enhanced catalogue, for the first time, allows a detailed analysis of induced seismicity during single hydraulic fracturing experiments, including the individual fracturing stages and the comparison between injection schemes. Beside the detailed study of the spatio-temporal patterns, event clusters and the growth of seismic clouds, we estimate relative magnitudes and b-values of AEs for conventional, cyclic progressive and dynamic pulse injection schemes, the latter two being fatigue hydraulic fracturing techniques. While the conventional fracturing leads to AE patterns clustered in planar regions, indicating the generation of a single main fracture plane, the cyclic progressive injection scheme results in a more diffuse, cloud-like AE distribution, indicating the activation of a more complex fracture network. For a given amount of hydraulic energy (pressure multiplied by injected volume) pumped into the system, the cyclic progressive scheme is characterized by a lower rate of seismicity, lower maximum magnitudes and significantly larger b-values, implying an increased number of small events relative to the large ones. To our knowledge, this is the first direct comparison of high resolution seismicity in a mine-scale experiment induced by different hydraulic fracturing schemes. KW - Fracture and flow KW - Spatial analysis KW - Statistical methods KW - Time-series analysis KW - Induced seismicity Y1 - 2020 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1093/gji/ggaa127 SN - 0955-419X SN - 1365-246X VL - 222 IS - 1 SP - 189 EP - 206 PB - Oxford Univ. Press CY - Oxford ER - TY - GEN A1 - Cesca, Simone A1 - Stich, Daniel A1 - Grigoli, Francesco A1 - Vuan, Alessandro A1 - López-Comino, José Ángel A1 - Niemz, Peter A1 - Blanch, Estefanía A1 - Dahm, Torsten A1 - Ellsworth, William L. T1 - Reply to: Multiple induced seismicity mechanisms at Castor underground gas storage illustrate the need for thorough monitoring T2 - Nature communications Y1 - 2022 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30904-5 SN - 2041-1723 VL - 13 IS - 1 PB - Nature Research CY - Berlin ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Cesca, Simone A1 - Sugan, Monica A1 - Rudzinski, Lukasz A1 - Vajedian, Sanaz A1 - Niemz, Peter A1 - Plank, Simon A1 - Petersen, Gesa A1 - Deng, Zhiguo A1 - Rivalta, Eleonora A1 - Vuan, Alessandro A1 - Linares, Milton Percy Plasencia A1 - Heimann, Sebastian A1 - Dahm, Torsten T1 - Massive earthquake swarm driven by magmatic intrusion at the Bransfield Strait, Antarctica JF - Communications earth and environment N2 - An earthquake swarm affected the Bransfield Strait, Antarctica, a unique rift basin in transition from intra-arc rifting to ocean spreading. The swarm, counting similar to 85,000 volcano-tectonic earthquakes since August 2020, is located close to the Orca submarine volcano, previously considered inactive. Simultaneously, geodetic data reported up to similar to 11 cm north-westward displacement over King George Island. We use a broad variety of geophysical data and methods to reveal the complex migration of seismicity, accompanying the intrusion of 0.26-0.56 km(3) of magma. Strike-slip earthquakes mark the intrusion at depth, while shallower normal faulting the similar to 20 km long lateral growth of a dike. Seismicity abruptly decreased after a Mw 6.0 earthquake, suggesting the magmatic dike lost pressure with the slipping of a large fault. A seafloor eruption is likely, but not confirmed by sea surface temperature anomalies. The unrest documents episodic magmatic intrusion in the Bransfield Strait, providing unique insights into active continental rifting. Y1 - 2022 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1038/s43247-022-00418-5 SN - 2662-4435 VL - 3 IS - 1 PB - Springer Nature CY - London ER -