TY  - JOUR
A1  - Ryo, Masahiro
A1  - Jeschke, Jonathan M.
A1  - Rillig, Matthias C.
A1  - Heger, Tina
T1  - Machine learning with the hierarchy-of-hypotheses (HoH) approach discovers novel pattern in studies on biological invasions
JF  - Research synthesis methods
N2  - Research synthesis on simple yet general hypotheses and ideas is challenging in scientific disciplines studying highly context-dependent systems such as medical, social, and biological sciences. This study shows that machine learning, equation-free statistical modeling of artificial intelligence, is a promising synthesis tool for discovering novel patterns and the source of controversy in a general hypothesis. We apply a decision tree algorithm, assuming that evidence from various contexts can be adequately integrated in a hierarchically nested structure. As a case study, we analyzed 163 articles that studied a prominent hypothesis in invasion biology, the enemy release hypothesis. We explored if any of the nine attributes that classify each study can differentiate conclusions as classification problem. Results corroborated that machine learning can be useful for research synthesis, as the algorithm could detect patterns that had been already focused in previous narrative reviews. Compared with the previous synthesis study that assessed the same evidence collection based on experts' judgement, the algorithm has newly proposed that the studies focusing on Asian regions mostly supported the hypothesis, suggesting that more detailed investigations in these regions can enhance our understanding of the hypothesis. We suggest that machine learning algorithms can be a promising synthesis tool especially where studies (a) reformulate a general hypothesis from different perspectives, (b) use different methods or variables, or (c) report insufficient information for conducting meta-analyses.
KW  - artificial intelligence
KW  - hierarchy-of-hypotheses approach
KW  - machine learning
KW  - meta-analysis
KW  - synthesis
KW  - systematic review
Y1  - 2019
U6  - https://doi.org/10.1002/jrsm.1363
SN  - 1759-2879
SN  - 1759-2887
VL  - 11
IS  - 1
SP  - 66
EP  - 73
PB  - Wiley
CY  - Hoboken
ER  -