TY - JOUR A1 - van Velzen, Ellen A1 - Thieser, Tamara A1 - Berendonk, Thomas U. A1 - Weitere, Markus A1 - Gaedke, Ursula T1 - Inducible defense destabilizes predator–prey dynamics BT - the importance of multiple predators JF - Oikos N2 - Phenotypic plasticity in prey can have a dramatic impact on predator-prey dynamics, e.g. by inducible defense against temporally varying levels of predation. Previous work has overwhelmingly shown that this effect is stabilizing: inducible defenses dampen the amplitudes of population oscillations or eliminate them altogether. However, such studies have neglected scenarios where being protected against one predator increases vulnerability to another (incompatible defense). Here we develop a model for such a scenario, using two distinct prey phenotypes and two predator species. Each prey phenotype is defended against one of the predators, and vulnerable to the other. In strong contrast with previous studies on the dynamic effects of plasticity involving a single predator, we find that increasing the level of plasticity consistently destabilizes the system, as measured by the amplitude of oscillations and the coefficients of variation of both total prey and total predator biomasses. We explain this unexpected and seemingly counterintuitive result by showing that plasticity causes synchronization between the two prey phenotypes (and, through this, between the predators), thus increasing the temporal variability in biomass dynamics. These results challenge the common view that plasticity should always have a stabilizing effect on biomass dynamics: adding a single predator-prey interaction to an established model structure gives rise to a system where different mechanisms may be at play, leading to dramatically different outcomes. KW - phenotypic plasticity KW - inducible defense KW - stability KW - synchronization KW - predator-prey dynamics Y1 - 2018 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1111/oik.04868 SN - 0030-1299 SN - 1600-0706 VL - 127 IS - 11 SP - 1551 EP - 1562 PB - Wiley CY - Hoboken ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Yamamichi, Masato A1 - Klauschies, Toni A1 - Miner, Brooks E. A1 - van Velzen, Ellen T1 - Modelling inducible defences in predator-prey interactions BT - assumptions and dynamical consequences of three distinct approaches JF - Ecology letters N2 - Inducible defences against predation are widespread in the natural world, allowing prey to economise on the costs of defence when predation risk varies over time or is spatially structured. Through interspecific interactions, inducible defences have major impacts on ecological dynamics, particularly predator-prey stability and phase lag. Researchers have developed multiple distinct approaches, each reflecting assumptions appropriate for particular ecological communities. Yet, the impact of inducible defences on ecological dynamics can be highly sensitive to the modelling approach used, making the choice of model a critical decision that affects interpretation of the dynamical consequences of inducible defences. Here, we review three existing approaches to modelling inducible defences: Switching Function, Fitness Gradient and Optimal Trait. We assess when and how the dynamical outcomes of these approaches differ from each other, from classic predator-prey dynamics and from commonly observed eco-evolutionary dynamics with evolving, but non-inducible, prey defences. We point out that the Switching Function models tend to stabilise population dynamics, and the Fitness Gradient models should be carefully used, as the difference with evolutionary dynamics is important. We discuss advantages of each approach for applications to ecological systems with particular features, with the goal of providing guidelines for future researchers to build on. KW - Adaptive dynamics KW - fitness gradient KW - inducible defence KW - optimal trait KW - phenotypic plasticity KW - predator-prey dynamics KW - reaction norm KW - switching function Y1 - 2019 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1111/ele.13183 SN - 1461-023X SN - 1461-0248 VL - 22 IS - 2 SP - 390 EP - 404 PB - Wiley CY - Hoboken ER -